NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – identity of employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant made an application for a remedy in respect of his dismissal by his employer, which he identified as ‘3D Scaffolding’ – a Form F3 – Employer Response to Unfair Dismissal Application (Form F3) was filed by Steric Solutions P/L – Steric Solutions filed the Form F3, rather than an entity identified as ‘3D Scaffolding’, because Steric Solutions asserted that, at all relevant times, it was the employer of the applicant – 3D Scaffolding P/L also said the proper employer was, at all relevant times, Steric Solutions – applicant maintained that 3D Scaffolding P/L and not Steric Solutions was his employer – necessary to determine the identity of the applicant’s employer – there were a number of companies that made up the group of companies owned and operated by various members of the Docherty family (Docherty Group Companies) – they were 3D Scaffolding Admin P/L, 3D Scaffolding P/L and Steric Solutions P/L – not surprising if the complex web of arrangements was beyond the comprehension of an unskilled (non-family member) employee of any of the Docherty Group Companies – when there were group company arrangements in place most employees paid little attention to who might be their actual employing entity so long as they got paid each week for the work they did – Commission held that in the corporate labyrinth that was the Docherty Group Companies it was suggestive of a situation where, as between 3D Scaffolding (and its employees and owners) and Steric Solutions (and its employees and owners), there was a sharing of control and supervision of the applicant – consequently, the issue of the possibility of joint employment might arise – Damevski v Guidice and FP Group P/L v Tooheys P/L considered – Commission satisfied that Steric Solutions was, at all times, the real and effective employer of the applicant – Order amending the name of the respondent issued with the decision – matter to be relisted to determine whether the dismissal of the applicant by Steric Solutions was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – directions to be issued. Trialonas v 3D Scaffolding P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by United Firefighters’ Union (UFU) pursuant to s.739 FW Act 2009 – dispute involved Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board (MFB) investigation of conduct of MFB employee with view to consideration of disciplinary action against him – dispute raised under dispute resolution term in Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board, United Firefighters Union of Australia, Operational Staff Agreement 2010 (Agreement) – UFU submitted MFB failed to comply with its policies, procedures and practices under the Agreement or alternatively intended to change or amend its policies and procedures without engaging in consultative process – MFB became aware of allegedly offensive Facebook posts alleged to have been made by the employee – on three separate occasions MFB advised employee an investigation had commenced into alleged breaches of Metropolitan Fire Brigades Act 1958 (Vic) (MFB Act) or MFB policies as a result of Facebook comments – MFB advised employee a report for the Chief Officer of findings and recommendations would be prepared and if any allegations were substantiated disciplinary action may be taken against him including formal counselling, an adverse report, or formal charges being laid under s.78B of MFB Act – employee subsequently suspended from duty with pay – MFB submitted formal or informal counselling would have been inappropriate in the circumstances – UFU submitted MFB had not laid charges under disciplinary process thus not complied with MFB disciplinary investigation guidelines by suspending the employee prior to laying of charges under disciplinary process – UFU submitted in dealing with allegations against the employee MFB intended to change or amend its policies and procedures without engaging in consultative process – MFB submitted no intention to change or amend its policies and procedures – Commission satisfied dispute within scope of Agreement’s disputes resolution clause – found MFB did not fail to comply with its policies, procedures and practices prior to commencement of formal investigation to consider/determine whether it was appropriate to formally or informally counsel the employee under Operations Work Instruction, Counselling Procedures – found MFB did not fail to comply with its policies, procedures and practices by suspending employee prior to laying charges contrary to Disciplinary Investigation Guidelines or in dealing with the allegations against the employee – nor did MFB intend to change or amend its policies and procedures without engaging in any consultative process in dealing with the allegations against the employee – application dismissed. United Firefighters’ Union of Australia v Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – ss.384, 386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – jurisdictional objection – whether applicant satisfied small business minimum employment period of 12 months – applicant submitted he was a casual employee with respondent from June 2013 until late February 2017 – respondent contended applicant commenced employment from August 2014 – submitted that in November 2016 applicant ceased to work for the respondent, then was re-employed later that month – claimed the break in applicant’s employment meant applicant was not employed for a continuous period of 12 months – Commission held there was no cessation of employment relationship in November 2016 – applicant did not abandon employment as he attempted to communicate with respondent’s General Manager daily from 4 November to 17 November 2016 to determine when he could return to work – nor did applicant resign as no written resignation provided and no evidence of applicant having communicated resignation to others – applicant’s attendance at Centrelink to obtain employment separation certificate did not amount to resignation – held applicant was employed for at least the minimum employment period – respondent’s jurisdictional objection dismissed – matter to be listed for directions hearing. Cooper v A and A Excavations & Landscapes P/L

Twenty eight unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications will be heard by Fair Work Commissioner today. The list is: Equity Valet Parking Pty Ltd (Lynch), State Revenue Office (Tucker), Serco Australia Pty Ltd (Ramos), Queensland Property Investments Pty Limited (Gibson), Barada Barna Aboriginal Corporation (Dargan, Roos), Blenners Transport Qld Pty Ltd (Collocott), Modern India Pty Ltd (Patel), Viatek Pty Ltd (Newell), Victorian Building Authority (Forrest), ACES Incorporated (Martin), Artcraft Pty Ltd (Alverson), Royal Wolf Trading Australia Pty Ltd (Abbott), Challenge North Shore, Precision Assembly (Bakri), Blooms the Chemist Management Services (Cameron), Star Track Express Pty Ltd (Williams), South Bexley Service Centre Pty Limited (Paloumpis), Southern Cross Mining Services Pty Ltd (Carlier), Specialist Diagnostic Services Pty Ltd (Wringley), St Vincent De Paul Society (Campbell), Delta Hyrdaulics Pty Ltd (Schier), Data Processors Pty Ltd (Dowd), Mungabareena Aboriginal Corporation (Murray), Rivalea (Australia) Pty Ltd (Howard), Eastside Protection (Barrett), Fat Prophets Pty Ltd (Parkes), Westpac Banking Corporation (Sureka), Ranstad Pty Ltd (now HCA) (Snelling).

Its hardly worth the Fair Work Commissioners getting out of bed to hear only three labour dispute cases. The list includes: South Bexley Service Centre Pty Limited (Paloumpis), Andrew Kohn Pty Ltd (Scop), Australian Accident Management Commercial (‘AAMC’) Pty Ltd (Gioskos).

A spike in unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications will test the endurance of Fair Work Commissioners today. The full list is: Teys Australia Central Queensland Pty Ltd (Rodrigues), Star Track Express Pty Ltd (Williams), Spectrum Community Focus Limited (Valenzuela), Davidson Imports Pty Ltd (Goonewardene), ACE Operations Pty Ltd (Keighley), Carbridge Pty Ltd (Mazen), Falbury Pty Ltd (Layt), PPK Mining Equipment Pty Ltd (Barnden), Illawarrra Coal Holdings Pty Limited (Gosek), Early Links Inclusion Support Service Incorporated (Lee-Warner), Newcastle Permanent Building Society Limited (Weiss), Kalkamoning Pty Ltd (Fairman), Islamic Society of Victoria (Abou-Eid), Merriwa Industries Ltd (Bartlett), Apple (Harding), Virgin Australia Airlines Pty Ltd (Ingall), Morisset High School P&C Association (Burke, Dean), Krispy Kreme Australia Pty Ltd (Lally), National Union of Workers-New South Wales Branch (Herbert), Ceva Logistics (Australia) Pty Ltd (Sarpowan), Fieldforce Services Pty Ltd (Twigley), Wheadons Freight Management (Appleton), Australian Catering (Chen), RACV Cape Schanck Resort (Trembath), Luka Tippers and Excavation Pty Ltd (Everett), Omni Pty Ltd (Psalla), Department of Education and Training (Freeman), Barada Barna Aboriginal Corporation (Dargan, Roos), Bakers Club Worldwide Pty Ltd (Hall, Palibino), Mobile Computing Pty Ltd (Tye).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – contractor or employee – ss.382, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – whether small business minimum employment period of 12 months completed – whether extension of time required – applicant engaged as employee from 1 December 2015 – engaged by respondent from December 2011 – status of engagement between 2011 and 2015 disputed – multifactorial test for establishing whether engagement was subject to contract of employment or contract for services applied using French Accent v Do Rozario indicia – Commission ordered production of confidential financial information – found applicant engaged as an independent contractor between 1 December 2011 and 30 November 2015 – minimum employment period disputed – respondent was small business under s.383 FW Act – applicant submitted that he did not resign on 22 November 2016 but was directed to cease work due to stress from November 2016 to January 2017 – respondent submitted that applicant resigned verbally on 22 November 2016 – submitted that resignation was formally accepted on 29 November 2016 and final employment payments made the next day – Commission found that applicant began to dispute resignation on 7 December 2016 but did not do everything reasonably possible sooner to dispute or withdraw resignation – held that respondent allowed a reasonable time to elapse before acting on resignation – found that applicant had not completed minimum employment period for small business at time of termination – jurisdiction objection upheld – not necessary to consider application for extension of time – application for unfair dismissal dismissed. Brooker v Autolync t/a Autolync

CASE PROCEDURES – evidence – production of documents – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – on 25 May 2017 Order issued for production of documents directed to respondent – respondent objected to production of some documents 4, 10A, 10B, 11, 12 and 13B in Schedule of Order on grounds of relevance and commercial sensitivity – substantive matter related to whether respondent was required to facilitate the making of an in-house bid for garbage collection in Southern District of MCC – applicant submitted that documents sought have apparent relevance to the matter before Commission – that dispute is about application of Clause 6.2 of Moreland City Council Enterprise Agreement 2015 (Agreement) and how it applied in current circumstances – Commission held confidentiality or commercial sensitivity were not grounds alone on which to deny Order for production of documents but it may be grounds for placing restriction on inspection of documents [The Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers, Australia v Airly Coal P/L] – held Document 4 had some apparent relevance to issues that might arise – Commission not convinced that Documents 10A, 10B, 11 and 12 had any apparent relevance – held Document 13B, a comparison of bin lift costs, had some apparent relevance – held some restriction should be placed on inspection of Documents 4 and 13B due to commercial nature – ordered that documents should be made available for inspection by legal representatives of applicant and its Branch Secretary only – the documents and their contents were otherwise not to be disclosed to any person without further order of Commission – either party able to apply for a variation to Order – consent to such variation should be sought in the first instance. Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union v Moreland City Council