TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – remedy – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission required to determine appropriate remedy following respondent conceding that appellant’s termination of employment was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – Commission held at first instance reinstatement was not an appropriate remedy – awarded compensation of $64,655, the maximum amount of compensation permitted to be awarded to the appellant – appellant advanced a number of grounds of appeal, including that it would be in the public interest for the Commission to grant permission to appeal because the Decision undermined the statutory intention to make reinstatement the primary remedy for dismissal, and undermined public confidence in the Commission’s willingness to order reinstatement in appropriate cases – appellant further submitted that the public interest arose in circumstances where the Commission took into account the exercise by him of workplace rights (including taking legal proceedings against his employer) as a matter adverse to the conclusion that reinstatement was appropriate – Full Bench held appellant did not demonstrate an arguable case for appealable error, except in relation to taking into account the proceedings taken by him and others against Asciano, a related entity of the respondent, in the Federal Court – however Full Bench not persuaded that this by itself was sufficient to attract the public interest – Decision at first instance demonstrated the Commission considered there were a range of considerations militating against reinstatement, and it was apparent the Federal Court litigation played only a minor part in the analysis – held the matter turned on its particular facts, and the appeal raised no issue of general importance or legal principle – having regard to the substantial amount of compensation ordered as a remedy Full Bench did not consider the Decision manifested an injustice – held not in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by King against decision of Drake SDP of 17 March 2017 [[2017] FWC 1583] Re: Patrick Projects P/L
June 30, 2017
REGISTERED ORGANISATIONS – alteration of eligibility rules – s.158 Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 – application by Australian Security Industry Association Ltd (ASIAL) for consent to alteration of eligibility rules – applicant association sought consent to change Rule 5.2 ‘Classes of membership’ – effect of application to amend ‘Corporate Membership’ to extend membership to entities substantially engaged in the private security industry or otherwise approved for the purposes of obtaining a security licence under Australian law – to amend ‘Associate Membership’, ‘Individual Membership’ and ‘Affiliate Membership’ to clarify definitions – to amend Rule 5.3 ‘Corporate membership criteria’ to clarify criteria and ensure automatic transition from provisional to full corporate membership on fulfilment of criteria and to clarify voting and office bearing entitlements – original objection by AiGroup withdrawn after lengthy discussions with ASIAL and amendments to the proposed alteration’s wording – Commission satisfied compliance with requirements of RO Act and Regulations – consented to changes to eligibility rules sought by association – change to eligibility rules to take effect from 28 June 2017. Australian Security Industry Association Ltd
June 30, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – incapacity – ss.385, 387, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as daily hire meat processor – dismissed by letter on 27 January 2017 – reason for termination – excessive absence from the workplace – respondent submitted absence no longer a temporary absence – applicant unfit for work from 7 October 2016 because of non-work related illness – respondent provided with medical certificates which established applicant unfit for work from 3 January 2017 to 3 April 2017 – respondent inquired about applicant’s capacity as it was considering termination – applicant provided a show cause response establishing intention to return to work from 4 April 2017 onwards – at conciliation respondent’s reinstatement offer was rejected – respondent submitted to Commission any future orders should be restricted to reinstatement – applicant sought order for maximum compensation as she believed working relationship was damaged beyond repair and was concerned of potential victimisation – matter determined by determinative conference because limited factual disputes; language barrier; and parties were unrepresented – respondent apologised and accepted dismissal was unfair and they could not lawfully terminate applicant until after temporary absence had eventuated – respondent provided reassurances to applicant and re-encouraged applicant to consider offer of reinstatement – Commission provided applicant opportunity to reconsider – applicant declined offer – Commission satisfied applicant’s dismissal was unfair but not persuaded relationship had irretrievably broken down – accepted respondent’s apology and offer were genuine – found applicant’s refusal to return to work were unfounded in circumstances – found neither an order for compensation nor an order for reinstatement were appropriate – application dismissed – order dismissing application issued. Gumwel v JBS Australia P/L
June 30, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant dismissed for sending confidential and sensitive technical information off-site – applicant sent 30 workplace emails to personal email address – emails included dimensions of bank notes and intellectual property about features and suppliers – emails breached workplace policy – applicant intended to use emails addresses to request review of being denied a senior printing role, and alleged discrimination – applicant not dismissed until 13 days later – Commission found valid reason for dismissal – other matters considered including differential treatment, personal situation, health – found ‘on fine balance’ the dismissal was harsh and unreasonable – considered reinstatement inappropriate – additional information requested by Commission to enable consideration of compensation. Hemmingson v Note Printing Australia Limited
June 30, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contractor or employee – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant engaged as general labourer and scaffolder by respondent from January/February 2016 – applicant considered himself an employee – respondent raised jurisdictional objection – objected to classification of applicant as an employee – applicant received a text message from respondent in mid-March advising that it would not directly employ anyone anymore and would only engage sub-contractors – submitted that on 14 March 2017 his employment was terminated – claimed respondent continued to employ other staff – respondent did not attend hearing – Commission found applicant to be employee and protected from unfair dismissal – applicant provided evidence by way of payslips to show he was an employee – Commission found minimum employment period met – satisfied applicant’s employment terminated at initiative of respondent – applicant given neither reason nor any opportunity to respond prior to decision – dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable as no valid reason found for dismissal – Commission found applicant was unfairly dismissed – remedy – reinstatement not sought and not appropriate – compensation of $15,815.85 ordered. Keirl v Myrti P/L
June 30, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute under the Endeavour Energy Enterprise Agreement 2012 – dispute relates to applicant’s accrued long service leave – applicant argued that Endeavour had incorrectly applied clause 15 and Annexure D of the Agreement in its calculation of his accrued long service leave, which resulted in a reduction of his long service leave entitlement – Annexure D to the Agreement is a workplace arrangement known as the Integral Energy Supervisory Employees Workplace Arrangement 2003 (the WA) – applicant employed from 4 March 1986 working 36-hour week – changed from 36-hour week to 40-hour week on 21 January 2013 – Endeavour argued that the applicant’s interpretation of the relevant provisions meant that he was attempting to have his bank of long service leave which had accrued at 36 hours per week recalculated as having accrued as if he had worked 40 hours per week for the entirety of his service with Endeavour – Golden Cockerel considered – Agreement provides ‘applicable award derived long service leave terms’ and the applicant is entitled to long service leave in accordance with those terms – no basis for Commission to have recourse to the Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW) in determining this dispute – found that the plain meaning of clause 15 of the Agreement combined with clause 14 of the WA leads to the interpretation contended by Endeavour – the applicant’s long service leave balance for the 36-hour week period (ending on 21 January 2013) remains as it had been accrued in accordance with clause 15 of the Agreement as at that date. McWhirter v Endeavour Energy
June 30, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – small business employer – ss.382, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent made jurisdictional objection to application based on applicant not completing 6 months employment when terminated – applicant employed by Bank Australia on 3 October 2016 as Branch Manager – respondent submitted applicant’s employment was terminated in a meeting on 29 March 2017 – applicant submitted termination did not take effect until she received letter of termination on 5 April 2017 – evidence led by parties as to nature and effect of meeting on 29 March 2017 – respondent submitted at meeting applicant was advised her performance was unsatisfactory and thus was being terminated immediately – applicant handed back keys and collected some personal belongings – applicant was then paid her entitlements and provided confirmation of termination on 3 April 2017 – evidence led that on day of meeting applicant asked to be removed from a social media chat group as a result of termination – applicant submitted respondent did not make it clear in meeting she was terminated but was advised her performance would be assessed over the coming month – applicant submitted no notes taken in meeting – that she left meeting with intention of going to doctor as she was ill – as she knew she would be absent she handed back keys – applicant submitted her discussion around the social media chat was a poor choice of words – applicant also submitted her contract of employment required 4 weeks’ notice of termination thus termination could not have been immediate – Commission satisfied evidence confirmed applicant was terminated at meeting on 29 March 2017 – Commission not satisfied with applicants reasoning for her actions – Commission found applicants contract did not preclude immediate termination during probation – found applicant not a person who is protected from unfair dismissal as had not completed 6 months employment – application dismissed. Raven v Bank Australia Limited t/a Bank Australia
June 30, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contract for specified term – ss.385, 386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – preliminary matter – Commission required to determine whether applicant had been ‘dismissed’ in accordance with s.386 of the Act – applicant commenced employment with the respondent in 2005 – respondent submitted that applicant was employed under a fixed term contract ending 31 December 2016 – issue for determination was whether the applicant was a person employed under a contract of employment for a specified period of time – it was submitted that Conditions of Employment incorporated in the contract suggested that employment was ongoing – relevant clause of the Conditions of Employment was ‘should the incumbent be unsuccessful in obtaining a similar position in the current or any other Catholic school, he/she shall have security if employment’ – respondent submitted that it had no on-going obligations as a consequence of the Conditions of Employment as applicant failed or declined to apply for any other positions – respondent submitted that applicant was eligible to apply for three other positions – applicant submitted that such discussions with respondent were vague and no details were given – Commission satisfied that while applicant was appointed in her role for a specified period of time, the incorporated Conditions of Employment meant that the applicant had an on-going contract of employment if she was not reappointed to such position at the end of the specified period – held that applicant was ‘dismissed’ in accordance with the FW Act – employment terminated on employer’s initiative – application to be relisted to hear substantive unfair dismissal claim. Wiener v The Congregation of Presentation Sisters (WA) Incorporated t/a Iona Presentation College