Seventeen unfair dismissal and labour dispute applicants will be heard in the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Joely Ann Cavanagh (Clarke), Anglo Coal (Moranbah North Management) Pty Ltd (Wilson), Swing Shift Nurses (Tysoe), Mallee District Aboriginal Services Limited & Kirby (Connelly), Foxtel Management Pty Ltd (Tanyi), Audi Enterprises Pty Ltd (Caine, Zintchenko), RSPCA WA (Read), Causeway Holdings Pty Ltd (Wingate), iiWorks (Rise), South Sydney Junior Rugby League Club Pty Ltd (He), Northstar (Kamire), The Uniting Church in Australia Property Trust (Kolobius), Illawarra Coal Holdings Pty Ltd (McLachlan), Fincar Pty Ltd (Phillipson), PPK Mining Equipment Pty Ltd (Barnden).
September 14, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – termination of agreement – s.225 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Murdoch University for termination of the Murdoch University Enterprise Agreement 2014 (Agreement) after its nominal expiry date on 30 June 2016 – Agreement covered approximately 3500 employees, including academic and professional staff – Murdoch submitted it was suffering financially and contended the reason for bringing application was to free itself of constraints and impediments in Agreement to enable it to become more agile in meeting new challenges within constantly changing, globally competitive education landscape – submitted it was considering a number of new projects which could create 21,000 full time jobs and create research opportunities, but some provisions in Agreement could slow or inhibit projects from being implemented – Unions contended evidence did not support conclusion Agreement was the cause of Murdoch’s financial situation nor did it prevent Murdoch from addressing challenges – Murdoch took issue with 24 of the Agreement’s 110 clauses in relation to staff behaviour, workplace change, ability to control workforce numbers, and other clauses it claimed to add expense and/or involve inefficiency – Commission accepted clauses viewed as problematic and considered whilst similar clauses could be found in other universities agreements, in some circumstances, these clauses imposed significant constraints on how Murdoch operated and managed its employees – further held some clauses were overly prescriptive and unwieldy which hindered Murdoch from making changes to respond to its financial circumstances – bargaining thus far had been unsuccessful – Commission noted negotiations have been lengthy with little movement on both sides – Commission concluded no reason to believe parties were likely to settle agreement in foreseeable future – Aurizon considered in relation to public interest – Commission held evidence showed there would be small positive impact for state and national economies if Agreement terminated – Commission disagreed with Unions’ contentions that terminating Agreement would undermine public benefits of University and academic freedom – considered views of employees covered by Agreement, indicating strong opposition to termination – Commission satisfied termination of Agreement not contrary to public interest and held it may support good faith bargaining – Commission satisfied if Agreement is terminated Murdoch would have fewer constraints on how it managed employees and operations which will support it in its endeavours to improve its financial circumstances – Commission considered if Agreement is terminated, this will promote further bargaining – higher likelihood parties will successfully complete negotiations for new agreement – Commission satisfied appropriate to terminate Agreement – termination of Agreement to operate on and from 26 September 2017 – application granted. Murdoch University Enterprise Agreement 2014
September 14, 2017
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – plain language – ss.134, 156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – decision finalises second tranche of modern awards in plain language project – jurisdictional issue advanced by ACTU rejected – ACTU submission fails to appreciate nature of Commission’s task in Review and misconstrues modern awards objective – not necessary to make finding that modern award fails to satisfy one or more of s.134 FW Act considerations – s.134 does not set particular standard against which modern award can be evaluated – National Retail Association applied – variation of award in Review does not require finding that award is not simple or easy to understand – consideration in s.134(1)(g) FW Act is expressed in different terms to jurisdictional facts required to enliven discretion under s.160 FW Act – Full Bench not at liberty to ignore matter – Full Bench required to take into account in giving effect to modern awards objective in context of Review – number of parties opposed inclusion of particular awards in second tranche – resource implications of Review organisations acknowledged – this consideration cannot be determinative of scope of Review – s.156 FW Act imposes obligation on Commission to review all modern awards and each modern award must be reviewed in its own right – less weight given to views of industrial organisations now than previously due to shift in nature and purpose of modern awards – such considerations provide no warrant for exclusion of particular modern awards from plain language drafting – consultation process intended to ensure re-drafting process does not unintentionally alter legal effect of any award term – plain language redrafting project need not delay implementation of other award variations – decision specifies which awards will be included in tranche 2 of plain language drafting – various plain language drafting matters of general application addressed – exposure drafts to be updated to incorporate changes and republished for final comment. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Plain language re-drafting – Tranche 2 awards
September 14, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision concerning dispute arising under enterprise agreement – determined at first instance that agreement does not require payment of shift loading in addition to public holiday penalties to employees working on a public holiday – Full Bench satisfied appeal raises important issues of general application – attracts public interest – permission to appeal granted – whether at principles relevant to construction of enterprise agreements correctly applied at first instance – whether construction of agreement correct – well established principles distilled and summarised in Golden Cockerel and reformulated in Berri – decision in Berri released after first instance decision in present matter – reformulation of principles in Berri does not change approach to task of construing agreement – apparent Deputy President did not have regard to purpose of relevant provisions in agreement in construing wording as clear and unambiguous – did not have regard for text of agreement viewed as a whole – conclusion reached by Deputy President not correct – meaning clear when disputed provisions are read in context of agreement as a whole and having regard to purpose of provisions – decision at first instance quashed – appeal upheld – Full Bench found employees entitled to afternoon or night shift allowances for ordinary hours worked on public holidays – obligation to pay shift loading in addition to public holiday penalties arises. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Dean DP of 24 May 2017 [[2017] FWC 1763] Re: Endeavour Coal P/L t/a Appin Mine
September 14, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – decision at first instance found appellant had not been dismissed within meaning of s.386(1) of FW Act – appellant lodged appeal application 2 minutes out of time – Full Bench found minimal length of delay and lack of prejudice to respondent outweighed the lack of an explanation for delay – extension of time granted – appellant raised 15 grounds of appeal emphasising that he had been bullied at work over a long period and that he had suffered from mental illness at time he resigned – appellant submitted he had not been given a proper opportunity to present evidence relating to his mental illness – Full Bench found no evidence that Commission at first instance did not have regard to all the material filed and afford it the appropriate weight – found no evidence that respondent was aware of appellant’s mental health issues – found appellant made a conscious decision to resign – not satisfied that grounds of appeal raised an arguable case of error – no case made out that Commission’s conclusion in first instance was unreasonable, manifested by any injustice or counter-intuitive – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Moore against decision of Platt C of 22 June 2017 [[2017] FWC 3380] Re: Newspot Holdings P/L t/a Newspot Motors
September 14, 2017
GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – ss.365, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision declining to extend time to appellant to file general protections dismissal application – application lodged beyond 21 day time limit – Commissioner at first instance held no exceptional circumstances warranting grant of extension of time – Full Bench held Commissioner directly addressed question of whether appellant had a reasonable opportunity to become aware of dismissal – permission to appeal refused – Full Bench held appeal does not raise issue of legal principle – decision not attended by sufficient doubt to warrant reconsideration – not in the public interest to grant permission to appeal. Appeal by Foyster against the decision of Ryan C of 23 June 2017 [[2017] FWC 1905] Re: Bunnings Group P/L
September 14, 2017
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – in July 2016 it was proposed that National Training Wage Schedule (NTW Schedule) be standardised and removed from all awards except Miscellaneous Award 2010 (Miscellaneous Award) and that NTW Schedule be incorporated into other awards by reference to Miscellaneous Award – in February 2017 Full Bench expressed provisional view that where parties requested that NTW Schedule be tailored to particular modern award, this would occur – in June 2017 Full Bench outlined that terms of award-specific NTW Schedules be inserted into modern awards where applications have been made to maintain award-specific schedules – further noted that where schedules were tailored to each award, schedules would be consistent with final plain language NTW Schedule – in August 2017 Full Bench finalised NTW Schedule to be inserted into Miscellaneous Award – parties invited to comment on proposed NTW Schedule – no comments received – award-specific schedules prepared based on finalised NTW Schedule and parties’ draft schedules – Ai Group noted potentially relevant qualifications included in standard NTW Schedule that have been excluded in AMWU draft schedule – AMWU invited to file submissions in response to Ai Group – AMWU’s submissions in reply of 7 April 2017 proposed inclusion of Civil Construction and Metal and Engineering Technical Traineeships AQF III in Building and Construction General On-site Award 2010 – CFMEU invited to file submissions on matters raised by AMWU – interested parties invited to file submissions on award-specific schedules – replies to follow. 4 yearly review of modern awards – National Training Wage
September 14, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appellant’s matter has long history dating back to 2013 when she was dismissed by the respondent – appellant contested decision which was dismissed in December 2014 – appellant appealed decision to a Full Bench of the QIRC and the Industrial Court of Queensland – both applications were dismissed and the appellant subsequently exhausted her rights in the Queensland system in 2015 – on 28 June 2016 appellant lodged application in the Fair Work Commission in respect of alleged unlawful termination of employment – this application was 904 days out of time – Commission found no exceptional circumstances to warrant extension of time and declined to exercise discretion to extend – appellants permission to appeal listed on 11 July 2017 – Full Bench at the hearing granted permission for the appellant to be represented by counsel having regard to the complexity of the matter and to allow it to be dealt with more efficiently – Full Bench observed it will rarely be appropriate to grant permission to appeal unless an arguable case of appealable error is demonstrated – appellant contends the Deputy President erred in granting permission to the respondent to be represented by lawyers and in refusing to grant an extension of time for filing her application and in dismissing it – Full Bench considered House v The King – having regard to the grounds of appeal, submissions of the parties, circumstances of the matter, Full Bench found nothing to suggest there was an arguable case the DP’s decision was affected by error – Full Bench also noted under the Fair Work Act, an applicant can only bring one claim – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Wanninayake against decision of Gooley DP of 15 may 2017 [[2017] FWC 2589] Re: Department of Natural Resources and Mines (DNRM)