TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – small family-run business – differing accounts as to conversations between applicant and owner’s son leading up to cessation of employment – Commission made factual findings on balance of probabilities that determined outcome of case – satisfied no communications between applicant and respondent constituted express termination of employment – no action by respondent either intended to end employment or had probable result of bringing employment relationship to an end [Barkla] – applicant’s employment was not terminated at respondent’s initiative – not a case in which applicant was forced to resign because of respondent’s conduct – found applicant was not dismissed within meaning of s.386 – application dismissed. Cooper v A and A Excavations & Landscapes P/L
September 28, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed by Coles Express petrol station – applicant dismissed on the basis of acting dishonestly by claiming she put fuel in her car to test the fuel pump and encouraging a co-worker to take fuel – applicant claimed other employees have stolen in the past and have not been dismissed and she was treated differently because she was a member of the Sikh religion – Commission considered whether dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – found valid reason for dismissal related to applicant’s conduct – found applicant acted dishonestly when she took fuel without paying, claimed to have forgotten to pay for fuel and encouraged coworker to take fuel – found no evidence that religion or culture influenced applicant’s dismissal – dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Garg v Eureka Operations P/L t/a Coles Express Brandon Park
September 28, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as office administrator on casual basis three days per week from 10 May 2011 until dismissal on 31 May 2017 – respondent asserted dismissal genuine redundancy – applicant contended redundancy a sham and dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable – application dealt with by determinative conference – Commission to determine whether respondent no longer required applicant’s job to be performed by anyone due to change in operational requirements – applicant offered full-time role within showroom but declined – Commission considered compliance with consultation obligations under clause 8 of Clerks – Private Sector Award 2010 – satisfied respondent complied with obligations – Commission considered if reasonable for the applicant to be redeployed within respondent’s enterprise – satisfied not reasonable for applicant to be redeployed – found dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy – application dismissed. Staniland v Stegbar P/L
September 28, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – apprehension of bias – ss.365, 372 Fair Work Act 2009 – general protections application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal – heard with concurrent s.372 non dismissal application – respondent agreed to resolve payment of leave and superannuation issues – applicant agreed to settlement – respondent paid settlement amount – applicant notified Commission that matters were not resolved – Commission notified parties stating parties reached in-principle agreement at conference therefore Commission unable to issue certificate – referred parties to decision in McCaffrey – parties directed to file submissions – applicant requested matter be heard by another Member – allegation of actual or apprehended bias based on Commissioner’s knowledge and reference to Workplace Protection Order against applicant entering Canberra Registry – necessary for applicant to demonstrate that a fair minded and informed observer might conclude a real possibility decision maker not impartial – no doubt parties reached agreement in conference – conference falls within first category in Masters v Cameron – irrelevant applicant did not sign terms of settlement – agreement extinguished original course of action and replaced with new course based on agreement – satisfied application resolved by settlement at conference – adopted reasoning in McCaffrey – Commission declined to issue certificate. Hunter v Anthony Costello Automotive
September 28, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant dismissed for serious misconduct – involved banned practice of accepting gifts from passing boats – both respondents’ valid reason for dismissal and lack of any significant procedural unfairness weighed against finding dismissal unfair – whether dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable – applicant acted in breach of respondent’s policy – constituted valid reason for termination – applicant not explicitly and clearly notified dismissal was possible outcome of performance improvement meeting – applicant given opportunity to respond – decision to terminate not predetermined – other relevant matters including significant impact of dismissal on applicant’s personal and economic situation considered – unlikely to secure alternative employment – unblemished employment history – found summary dismissal a disproportionate response – several mitigating circumstances – applicant unfairly dismissed – reinstatement ordered – continuity of service and partial restoration of pay. Clements v Downer EDI Works P/L
September 28, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – abandonment – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant’s request for annual leave in April denied – warned employment may be terminated if she did not attend work during leave request period – applicant did not attend for work on 10 April or any time thereafter – filed unfair dismissal application – Commission found actual reason for applicant’s dismissal was refusal to comply with instruction to attend work – found employer’s refusal approve April leave request unreasonable – employer’s 13 and 21 April communications represented inappropriate and inaccurate notification of dismissal – found no valid reason for dismissal – unreasonable and unjust process – dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable – 16 week’s compensation ordered. Stevens v Horsley Park Supermarket P/L t/a Carlo’s IGA Horsley Park
September 28, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a CNC machinist – role required him to bend over machines for a long time – claimed this had resulted in the significant exacerbation and acceleration of an underlying degenerative disc disease – respondent submitted the applicant had never raised any problems he was having with his back – applicant was given a difficult job that would have required him to bend over a machine for 10 to 12 hours – applicant refused job citing back pain – respondent submitted applicant was seeking more money – said if the applicant was not going to do the job he would ‘have to leave the company now’ – audio recording of meeting between parties admitted into evidence – Commission found applicant did not refuse to perform the task because of the state of his lower back, but because he thought he should be paid more – found applicant was not unfairly dismissed – application dismissed. Zhang v Meeke Engineering
September 27, 2017
The Fair Work Commission will process twenty unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications today. The full list is: Audi Enterprises Pty Ltd (Caine, Zintchenko), Inco Ships (Lewer), St Augustines Catholic Church Melbourne (Pritchard), Emergency Services Telecommunications Authority (De Lany), Australia Post Corporation (Hachim), Federation University Australia (Wong), Baker Hughes Australia Pty Limited (Manescu), Griffin Coal Mining Company Pty Ltd (King), Lady of Grace Fraternity & Hogarth and Others, Estia Investments Pty Ltd (Laird, Tamvakis), Coal Services Pty Limited (Land), Glencore Coal (NSW) Processing Pty Ltd (Groves), Bulga Coal Management Pty Limited (Newton & Hartcher), Federation Training (Sheehan), Vitasoy Australia Products Pty Ltd (Barter), Are You Cool Enough Refrigeration Contractors Pty Ltd (Nissanka), Australia Post (Sambastian), Land Surveys No Problems Just Solutions Pty Ltd (Rice).