NEWS HR

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – s.418 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for orders to stop unprotected industrial action by certain employees at Port Melbourne factory and the CFMMEU – Commission found incidents of labour hire refusal, shift team leader refusal, stoppages and a Saturday absence constituted industrial action – USG Boral & CFMEU Port Melbourne Production & Distribution Employees Enterprise Agreement 2015 had not passed its nominal expiry date – unprotected industrial action found to be happening or probable but found no evidence action organised by the CFMMEU – orders against industrial action made in relation to employees – CFMMEU argued orders should be no longer than 24 hours – Commission stated 24 hours insufficient given industrial action by employees cannot be protected until nominal expiry date of Agreement has passed – orders effective until 31 July 2018. USG Boral Building Products P/L t/a USG Boral v Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as store manager – dismissed for alleged fraudulent activity – Commission found no valid reason for dismissal – no warning of dismissal – no opportunity to respond – no procedural fairness – dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable – compensation assessed in accordance with Sprigg formula – ordered compensation of $22,329, taxed according to law. McGlashan v The Entrance Discount Variety P/L t/a The Base Warehouse

The queue for a hearing before Fair Work Commission goes around the block. Over 80 unfair dismissal/labour dispute applicants remain on the law list: Shoreline Caravan Park (Barone), A E Cartage Pty Ltd (Andersen), Coles Supermarket (De Maniel), Total Family Care Pty Ltd (Earle), Beninati Group P/L (Hutchinson), Comfort Management Pty Ltd (Yang), Southern Metropolitan Cemeteries Trust (Blackmore), Australian Self-Medication Industry Limited & Schoombie (Atkins), Windsor Leagues Club Ltd (Leonard), Australia Western Railroad Pty Ltd (Watson), E.L.K. Pty Ltd (Chadwick), ALH Group Ltd (Baines), Doutta Galla Aged Services Limited (Devi), ISS Facility Service (Virk), Ramsay Health Care (Buksh), Gold Coast Hospitality Services Pty Ltd (Ozturk), Japara (Pettit), The Hills Christian Community School Inc (Kelly), Commonwealth Bank of Australia (Zepidis), Boral Resources (NSW) Pty Limited & Burton (Kerslake), Drake Australia Pty Ltd (Baldacchino), Healthscope Operations Pty Ltd (Bridgwater), Platinum KS2 Pty Ltd ATF Platinum KS2 Trust (Kozmanyan), Australia Pty Ltd v Tait (Spinifex), Dampmaster Pty L td (Thititanavanich), Thai Waterfront Restaurant (Inkum), Darwin Formwork Pty Ltd (Stone), Omnigas Services Pty Ltd (Dunne), Extragreen Holidays (Aust) Pty Ltd (Qureshi), Virgin Mobile (Rook), Community Accommodation and Respite Agency (Heggernan), MyBudget Pty Ltd (Andrawos), Flinders University (Lynd-Stevenson), Telstra Corporation (Robertson), Zero In Pty Ltd (Barone), A E Cartage Pty Ltd (Andersen), Total Family Care Pty Ltd (Earle), Metro Trains Melbourne Pty Ltd (Crawford), Q Hospitality Group Pty Ltd (Lyons), NWQIC SS (James), Two Shores Holiday Village (Morley), ECS International Security and Investigations (Kumar), Tee-Zed Products Pty Ltd (Manna), Australian Concert & Entertainment Security Pty Ltd (Magpayo), Steller Residential Pty Ltd (Maher), Paston Pty Ltd (Masivoivoi), Illaroo Co-operative Aboriginal Corporation (Kelly), Ecolab (Rodriguez), St Vincent’s Hospital Melbourne (Horsburgh), Goulburn Valley Health (Ahmad), Victoria Police (Brierley, Chuck), MECWA (Pamamull), DCML Hodgson (Khaira), GV Hotel (Rogers), ACT Government – Transport Canberra and City Services (Rodger), Sensis Pty Ltd (Wiseman), Dick’s Pumping Service (Bonnes), The Uniting Church in Australia Property Trust (Q) (Keft), Sakuraya Holdings Pty Ltd (Dinh), Smithfield Smash Repairs Pty Ltd (Juras), African Communities Council of SA Inc (Gatabazi, Gabremariam), Maroochy Coach House Holdings Pty Ltd (Watson), Temahl (Aust) Pty Ltd (Goldspring), Commonwealth Bank Group (Haque), Elite Essential Trades Pty Ltd (Gauntlett-Gilbert), HCL Australia Services Pty Limited (Amba), G4S Australia Pty Ltd (Thomas), St Vincent de Paul Society (NSW) (McLane), Rosscarbery Holdings Pty Ltd (Jadach), The Islamic Society of Victoria Inc (Abou-Eid), Watpac Construction Pty Ltd (McNamara & McNamara and Others), Trustees of the Edmund Rice Education Australia (Butler), Sunshine Coast Labour Hire (Smith), Wet Fix Pty Ltd (Bennion), The Hills Christian Community School Inc (Kelly), ABC Transport (Stepanovich), Flehan Brothers Pty Ltd (Abete), Kioussis Nominees Pty Ltd (Mantovano).

Twelve applicants await their day in the Fair Work Tribunal. The unfair dismissal/labour dispute lawlist is: Pittwater RSL Club Inc (Caruso), Pizza Pizza Pty Ltd (Coles), Delicado Foods Pty Ltd (Mbengue), FOODORA Australia Pty Ltd (Klooger), Warrigal Care (Poposki), David Jones Limited (Strohfeldt), Teleperformance Australia (Sharma), Trustee for Maddingley Montessori Centre Unit Trust (Yadav), Nexus Inc (Prichard), Artha Property Group Pty Ltd (Dunn), Powerflow Systems Pty Ltd (King), BOGEYE Pty Ltd (Tweedie).

An application for variation of the FlameSafe Fire Protection Pty Limited and the CEPU NSW Union/NFIA NSW Sprinkler Fitting/Fire Protection Enterprise Agreement NSW & ACT 2015-2019 (s.210 – Application for approval of a variation of an enterprise agreement) is being sought from Deputy President Gostencnik in his Melbourne chambers.

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.589, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute referred to Commission under s.589 of FW Act – concerned whether employer had right to further implement fatigue alerting and distraction monitoring system and DVR Cameras recording footage of the driver and the road – Commission satisfied the continuous footage was capable of enabling employer to meet its obligation to ensure that work is performed in accordance with clause on safe systems of work of the Toll – TWU Enterprise Agreement 2017-2020 – capacity for footage to be used for a purpose other than to ensure safe driving adequately dealt with by policy – employer evidence established no safety concerns with DVR cameras – not persuaded that safety and privacy concerns should act as a barrier to the further implementation of the fatigue monitoring and DVR Cameras – Commission found reasonable step to ensure a safe system of work, pursuant to the Agreement. Toll Transport P/L t/a Toll Shipping v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contractor or employee – termination at initiative of employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent was labour hire business – applicant assigned to work as a casual employee at the Department of Justice (DOJ) – DOJ expressed concerns to respondent about applicant’s performance – respondent advised applicant her assignment had ceased without providing reasons – respondent submitted that while assignment had ceased, employment continued – ‘the contractual relationship between a labour hire company and a host employer cannot be used to defeat the rights of a dismissed employee seeking a remedy for unfair dismissal’ [Kool v Adecco] – Commission found that applicant had a reasonable expectation of continuing employment and worked on a regular and systematic basis – applicant not given an opportunity to respond to performance concerns – dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement not appropriate – ordered compensation of $15,000. Tait v Spinifex Australia P/L t/a Spinifex Recruiting

ANTI-BULLYING – constitutionally-covered business – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – respondent objected on the ground that it was not a constitutionally covered business and that the applicant did not meet the definition of ‘at work’ – Commission found applicant was employed by the government of New South Wales but that this did not preclude her from being ‘at work’ in the respondent – further found that the respondent is a constitutional corporation as it engages in sufficient trading activities to warrant the characterisation as a trading corporation – objections dismissed – applicant eligible to make application for order to stop bullying – matter to be listed for mention and directions. Ms Leeman