NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an unfair dismissal remedy – jurisdictional issue raised – application out of time by 82 days – applicant submitted representative error and was lead to believe by respondent dismissal was genuine redundancy – applicant became aware of the non-genuine nature of redundancy after dismissal – factual contest whether there was a redundancy – Kornicki v Telstra principles applied – Commission held applicant’s case not without merit or lacking in any substance – satisfied exceptional circumstances warranted granted an extension of time – exercised discretion to grant extension of time – referred for further programming. Irvine v Spandex Asia Pacific P/L t/a Spandex

ANTI-BULLYING – constitutionally-covered business – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – applicant employed as an Assessment Officer at Victorian Legal Aid – respondent objected on the ground that it was not a constitutionally covered business – respondent is a statutory legal aid body – the provision of legal aid and legal assistance services not considered a trading activity for present purposes – respondent’s overall activity is to provide its services gratuitously to the community using Government funds for a public policy purpose – Commission found respondent was not a trading corporation – no jurisdiction – application dismissed. Ms Robertson

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal – applicant employed as Branch Manager – summarily dismissed for an alleged pattern of unacceptable behaviour involving elements of racism and abuse of power – Commission found three of the allegations not to be true – in relation to two other events, found the applicant’s actions were inappropriate – held actions not serious enough to constitute a valid reason for the applicant’s dismissal – found dismissal to be harsh, unjust and unreasonable – satisfied reinstatement inappropriate – small discount to the amount of compensation payable due to misconduct – ordered compensation of $32,000 plus superannuation. Ward v Reece Limited t/a Reece Group P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – remedy – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – employee awarded $10,951.87 in decision at first instance (compensation decision) after Commission found he was unfairly dismissed in substantive decision [[2018] FWC 1336] – grounds of appeal that Commission erred in method used to calculate compensation and in finding that employee’s employment would have continued for six months – Full Bench observed decision at first instance determined dismissal of employee inevitable – Full Bench held Commission’s finding involved both an error of principle and significant error of fact – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld – compensation decision and order quashed – upon rehearing Full Bench considered personal circumstances of respondent – determined that an order for the payment of six weeks’ compensation was appropriate – ordered compensation of $6,730.77. Appeal by Hanson Construction Materials P/L against decision of Spencer C of 9 August 2018 [[2018] FWC 4369] Re: Darren Pericich

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – scope order – ss.185, 238, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission dismissed the AMWU’s application for a scope order as it was found that bargaining had not commenced – appeal on grounds that Commission erred in determining that an agreement had been made following 2017 vote as there was no valid request for vote in accordance with s.182(2) of the FW Act – grounds for appeal also included that even if an agreement had been made, engagement in bargaining had commenced as a result of correspondence from Broadspectrum – decision of Full Bench majority – considered whether 2017 vote to approve proposed agreement resulted in agreement being made in accordance with s.182(1) – Uniline considered – found notice of employee representational rights had not been issued to each employee who would be covered by the proposed 2017 agreement – held Commission erroneously found that no bargaining was occurring and AMWU application was not considered in accordance with FW Act – Full Bench majority found that bargaining was occurring – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld – decision at first instance quashed – application remitted to Asbury DP for rehearing – decision of Full Bench minority – found no appealable error in dismissal of AMWU’s application – would grant permission to appeal and dismiss the appeal. Appeal by Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union against decision of McKinnon C of 4 July 2018 [[2018] FWC 3974] Re: Broadspectrum (Australia) P/L

The Fair Work Commission lawlist for today is: Air Change Australia Pty Ltd (McCarthy), Clinical Laboratories Pty Ltd (Street), Healthcare Australia (Melo Gaete), St Joseph’s Flexible Learning Centre (Cowper), Gippsland & East Gippsland Aboriginal Cooperative Ltd (Ellis, Finn, Harvey, Oestamann, Patten), East Arnhem Regional Council (Deacon), Olympic FC (Sottile), Mike & Jan Pty Ltd (Passey), The Trustee for Seven Kay Investments Trust (Lewis), Safe Places Community Services Limited (Watson), Maritimo (Wolland), N & HM Cooper Motor Search (SA) & Car Clearance Centre (SA) (Badcock), Specialist Surgical Supplies (Pethick), Airservices Australia (Jones), Commonwealth Bank of Australia (Nguyen), Inglot Cosmetics Pty Ltd (Pavert), Bellagon Pty Ltd (Riddle), Secom Security Australia (Key), BG & TR Pty Ltd (Crisford), Winnaa Pty Ltd (Roos), G8 Education Limited (Wood), Japara Healthcare Limited (Conian), Sargeant Transport Pty Ltd (Costello), Sita Coaches Pty Ltd (Middedge, Small), Abbe Corrugated Pty Ltd (Sabani), Akkari Tilling Pty Ltd & Akkari Polishing (Gill), MECWA (Dudash), Visy Packaging Pty Ltd (Cromble, Stevens), Ausdrill Ltd (Julitz), National Australia Bank Limited (Vasquez), Gunlake Concrete NSW Pty Ltd (Siminsky), Byron Ventlink Pty Limited (Robinson-Gale), BHP Coal Pty Ltd (Macklin).

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – ss.365, 366 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal – application lodged seven days after 21 day time period – whether exceptional circumstances exist – applicant initially lodged unfair dismissal application 13 days after dismissal – applicant not employed for minimum employment period – unfair dismissal application beyond jurisdiction – applicant discontinued unfair dismissal application – asked Commission staff whether general protections application had a minimum employment period requirement – Commission staff confirmed no minimum employment period requirement – applicant sought legal advice and subsequently lodged general protections application – applicant submitted that respondent dismissed him because he made numerous enquiries regarding his pay and other operational and safety issues – Commission satisfied general protections application is not without merit – satisfied applicant acted reasonably promptly to lodge general protections application – satisfied there was an acceptable explanation for the delay – satisfied applicant acted promptly initially in challenging his dismissal by lodging unfair dismissal application – Commission satisfied there were exceptional circumstances – application for an extension of time granted – application to be listed for conference. Green v Bilco Group P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a community night patrol officer – dismissed for untruthfully recording his attendance at work – Commission satisfied applicant received counselling on a number of issues during his employment – satisfied applicant engaged in misconduct in incorrectly claiming time he had not worked – held applicant’s conduct was not above reproach and some sanction was warranted, however Commission not convinced that the conduct provided a valid reason for dismissal – not satisfied applicant was afforded procedural fairness – no valid reason for dismissal – process followed lacking in almost every respect – found dismissal was both harsh and unjust – applicant unfairly dismissed – remedy to be considered. Wunungmurra v East Arnhem Regional Council