NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contract for specified term – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed under three successive fixed term contracts – employment ended when last contract expired – whether applicant dismissed – applicant presumed further contract would be offered – no further fixed term contract offered – jurisdictional objection raised – respondent claimed no dismissal as employment ended at completion of fixed term contract – issue whether employment was terminated on respondent’s initiative or as a result of contract ending – Navitas considered – Commission satisfied applicant did not enter contract with respondent as result of misrepresentative or misleading conduct – found employment ceased in accordance with agreed terms in contract – termination of employment not at the initiative of respondent – jurisdictional objection upheld – application dismissed. Mateer v International Education Services Limited t/a IES Senior College

The unfair dismissal/labour dispute lawlist for the Fair Work Commissioners today is: Central Capital Pty Ltd (Zhou), Gaucho Bros Pty Ltd (Mathieu), Smartscape Pty Ltd (Thong), LOPIGEAR Pty Ltd (Neary), Krav Maga Defence Institute Pty Ltd (Markovitch), City of Stirling (Emery), Nutton 2 lt Pty Ltd (Bailey), Opteon (Kaur), Healthcare Australia (Melo Gaete), Pandjo Trading (Szczygielski), Killara Pines Pty Ltd (Danaher), Coverall Security Pty Ltd (Neumayer), Seljo (NT) Pty Ltd (Tiwari), Australian Federal Police (Burnett), DJ Rash Pty Ltd as trustee for DJ Rash Unit Trust (Pinkistone (nee Quinn)), Artha Property Group Pty Ltd (Dunn), Superior Wood Pty Ltd (Lee), Coles Supply Chain Pty Ltd (Milford), MedRecruit International Limited Partnership (Ownes), Aussie Yachting (Tindal), A Noble & Son Ltd (Mullins), Scavenger Supplies Pty Ltd (Pemberton).

The Fair Work Commission lawlist governing unfair dismissal and contract disputes is as follows: Ninas Cleaning Services & Ninas Cleaning Australia (Porter), Steel Central Pty Ltd (Currie), Seljo (NT) Pty Ltd (Tiwari), Spotless Services Australia Ltd (Cook), Jambo Security (Dittman), Wastetech Engineering Pty Ltd (Ferrai), Latrobe Regional Hospital (Scott), GBR Helicopters (Wright), Transit Australia Group (Kainzinger), Australian Postal Corporation (Monaghan), Bacalar Pty Limited (Young), Nationwide News Pty Ltd (Kumar), Lorna Jane Pty Ltd (Keats), WSP Australia Pty Limited (Pye), Australian Radio Towers Management Pty Ltd (Green), Lake Illawarra Pre-School and Kindergarten (Bond), Busways Blacktown Pty Ltd (Tadros), George Weston Foods Ltd (Botha), Busselton Golf Club Incorporated (O’Connell), The West Australian Ballet Company (Way), Parents Without Partners Victoria Inc (Humphris), Laurent Boulangerie Pty Ltd (Hirst), KDR Victoria Pty Ltd (Moran), Islamic Association Western Suburbs Sydney Inc & Cheema and Another (Tahir), Fast Cabinets Pty Ltd (Zhou), Apprentices Trainees Employment Limited t/as ATEL (Nolan), David Jones Pty Ltd & Carafa and Another (McDonald), Mecca Brands Pty Ltd (Sullivan), Monash University (Meaney), Central Cleaning Supplies (Aus) Pty Ltd (Littel), Western Plains Pork Pty Ltd (Semple), Metro Tasmania Pty Ltd (Wolfe), Seljo (NT) Pty Ltd (Tiwari), The West Australian Ballet Company (Way).

The unfair dismissal lawlist for the Fair Work Commission today is: Port of Newcastle (McShane), Premium Tyre Service Pty Ltd (Check), United Flashing & Roofing Pty Ltd (Jin), David Newton Real Estate Pty Ltd (Watson), Transport for NSW (Fussell, Hudson), Commonwealth Bank of Australia (Zepidis), The Trustee for the Storehouse Unit Trust (Pelle), Pilbara Iron Company (Service) Pty Limited (Tito), Clinical Laboratories Pty Ltd (Street), Superstop Auto Parts (Ting), Spectrum Migrant and Resource Centre (O’Beirne), Aussie Guard Rail Pty Ltd (Abbott), Golden Lor (Arrnanasco), co Containers (LEith), Latrobe Regional Hospital (Scott), Global Traffic Equipment Pty Ltd ATF (Ede), Scaffoldinghire.com Pty Ltd (Bell), Goulburn-Murray Rural Water Corporation (Davis), Suncorp Group Limited (Lloyd), David Newton Real Estate Pty Ltd (Watson), Shanahan’s Livestock Transport Pty Ltd (Pholi), Olsen Property Inevstments PTy Ltd (Toovey), Anglicare Central Qld (Oberg), Risk Insure Pty Ltd (Kelly).

RIGHT OF ENTRY – dispute over right of entry – ss.505, 508 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute between applicant and respondents about whether CFMMEU had coverage of relevant workers – applicant contended entry permit holders sought to speak to and possibly recruit union members on site – indicated CFMMEU not entitled to represent the industrial interests of certain persons employed at the premises – contended permit holders were not expressly authorised to take photographs or to make video recordings under State OHS law – contended Commission can make orders under s.508 of the FW Act – Commission found no evidence permit holders sought or purported to exercise any right of entry – amalgamation of three unions had taken effect – coverage issue no longer in dispute – digital material tendered – Commission permitted digital material because it was highly probative – noted type of conduct was neither conducive to rational decision making nor to the resolution of disputes – conduct in digital material symptomatic of underlying and central dispute as to coverage – found no evidence that conduct in video material likely to continue – found no standing to make an application under s.508 – s.505 not enlivened – held order unnecessary – application dismissed. Geofabrics Australasia P/L v Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union and Ors

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – deed of settlement – ss.394, 399A Fair Work Act 2009 – application to dismiss unfair dismissal application – respondent submitted that agreement and final settlement to resolve application had already been reached between the parties after a Member Assisted Conciliation had been conducted – Masters v Cameron considered and applied to factual findings – Commission found objective intention was to make a binding agreement to settle unfair dismissal matter – ancillary terms were to be confirmed later in written document – found binding settlement agreement existed – employer undertook to pay agreed amount contingent upon Commission’s finding – settlement amount of $8,000 now due and payable to applicant – application dismissed. Badcock v N & HM Cooper Motor Search (SA) and Anor

CASE PROCEDURES – stay order – ss.392, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – at first instance Commission found employee to have been unfairly dismissed – awarded $72,000 in compensation to be paid within 21 days – appellant’s primary ground of appeal that the amount of compensation was incorrectly calculated – decision at first instance calculated amount of compensation on basis of earnings at $3,080 per week – the $3,080 was related to the employee’s fortnightly earnings – employee accepted that decision at first instance incorrectly calculated his remuneration – Commission satisfied that permission to appeal would likely be granted – found balance of convenience weighed in favour of the appellant – satisfied that application for a stay order should be granted – stay order to take effect from 22 November 2018 and remain in force until further order of the Commission. Appeal by Australian Crane and Machinery P/L t/a Australian Crane and Machinery against decision of Cribb C of 23 October 2018 [[2018] FWC 6510] Re: Shakotko

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – remedy – compensation – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – Commission found applicant was unfairly dismissed [[2018] FWC 6280] – ordered respondent pay applicant compensation within 21 day time-frame – respondent requested variation of Order to pay compensation in instalments – Commission sought submissions and evidence – needed to be satisfied that respondent’s financial circumstances did not allow for a lump sum payment and could only manage 12 month instalment plan – respondent provided limited information about finances with a request for confidentiality – applicant opposed payment plan – Commission not satisfied variation of the Order supported except for the date of payment – respondent ordered to pay applicant lump sum of $3,025.20 taxed according to law plus 9.5% superannuation within 21 days of this decision. Miller v Urbanite Bikes P/L t/a Urban Pedaler