New Zealand Aluminium Smelters argued at the Court of Appeal that an Employment Court judgment wrongly interpreted the Holidays Act 1981. A longstanding Tiwai workers’ dispute about lieu days continues after smelter bosses took their case to the Court of Appeal. New Zealand Aluminium Smelters argued on Thursday that an Employment Court judgment was wrong, estimating it could cost the company millions of dollars. In May 2013, 64 Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union [rebranded E Tu] members won an Employment Relations Authority case they took against NZAS concerning the accrual of lieu days for 12-hour shift workers at the Tiwai Point smelter in Southland. E Tu lawyer Greg Lloyd said NZAS appealed the Employment Court’s interpretation of section 7A of the Holidays Act 1981 – an Act he said no longer existed. The appeal judges could not overrule an Employment Court decision and could only rule on points of law, he said. He was optimistic about winning the appeal. “Even if the smelter is correct and the judge got the interpretation wrong, I believe it would have little effect in the Employment Court decision. “The worst case scenario if they decide yes, is that the case will revert back to same Employment Court judge to reconsider.” NZAS chief executive Gretta Stephens said: “We await the judgement of the Court of Appeal. As the matter remains before the court, we will not be making any further comment at this time.” NZAS appealed an initial decision in favour of Tiwai workers at a two-day Employment Court hearing held in December 2013. The appeal was rejected in May 2014, and Tiwai Point smelter bosses then lodged an application to the Court of Appeal. The workers embroiled in the dispute were covered by three versions of individual employment agreements at the plant. The EPMU claimed that, since hundreds of employees shifted from eight-hour to 12-hour shifts at the plant about 20 years ago, the company had been incorrectly calculating their lieu day entitlements.
October 23, 2015
Coles Group Supply Chain Pty Ltd is facing an avalanche of s.739 claims (I want to work when it suits me) from an army of flexers (Collins/Medic/Alewyn/Roberts). Other cases include: Piotto Brothers Cement Flooring (Boccaccio), Compumenn National Pty Ltd (Scicluna), Australian Taxation Office (Boyle), Bundaberg Brewed Drinks Pty Ltd (Climas), James Cook University (Fisher), EasyLift (Camilleri), Scripture Union Queensland (Parslow), GrainCorp Operations Limited (Loft), Department of Education & Training, North-Eastern Victoria Region (Somasundaram), Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Toto), ISS Security Pty Limited (Cawley), Department of Human Services (Maude), Reds Global Pty Ltd (Rota), Shore Hire Pty Limited (Bartlekowski), Daoud Building Group Pty Ltd (Fan), Urban WA Real Estate Pty Ltd (Shannon).
October 22, 2015
Australian Leisure and Hospitality Group Pty Ltd is jousting with an ex-employee (Kerridge). Other employers making a grand a grand entrance today include: QT Hotels and Resorts Pty Ltd (Csontos), EnerMech Pty Ltd (Croft), Fraser Coast Anglican College (Ryan), JB Caravan (Yang), GranCorp Operations Limited (Loft), Transdev Melbourne Pty Ltd (Walpola), Wrightville Administration Pty Ltd (Williams), RD Jones Group (Tilbrook), CARA Inc (Nelpurackal), Commonwealth of Australia (Acting through and represented by the Department of Defence) (Jones), Westsides Meats Pty Ltd (Gangur), Medicrew Pty Ltd (Van Veenendaal), Royal Equipment Pty Ltd (Maunder), St Vincent de Paul Society NSW (Lisha), Chi Kin Krn Ma (Te Rangipuawhe), Save the Children Australia (Davis), Papuan Oil Search (Jurukovski), Asciano Services Pty Ltd (Waters), MacMohan Holdings Limited (Reeve), Royal Equipment Pty Ltd (Maunder), MRCN Pty Ltd (Fox), Hanson Heidelberg Cement Group (Ovenstone).
October 21, 2015
Case procedures – evidence – ss.185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeals – Full Bench – appeal against decision to refuse application to correct decision to approve University of Western Sydney Academic Staff Agreement 2014 (agreement) – unions argued footnote in agreement had been inadvertently deleted with unintended adverse financial results – application to correct decision dismissed at first instance – new evidence heard on appeal – in public interests to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal allowed – decision of Commissioner set aside on basis of new evidence – error in agreement to be corrected. Appeal by University of Western Sydney against decision of McKenna C of 15 July 2015 [[2015] FWC 4793] Re: National Tertiary Education Union
October 21, 2015
Termination of employment – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 392, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent claimed genuine redundancy – Commission found respondent did not comply with consultation requirements of enterprise agreement and did not meet statutory requirements of s.389(1)(b) of the FW Act – found not genuine redundancy – dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement not ordered as inequitable – compensation to consider all the circumstances of the case [Haigh v Bradken Resources] – compensation of 4 weeks’ pay ordered. Cvejic v Academy Services P/L
October 21, 2015
Termination of employment – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – application not made within 21 days of prescribed time limit – reasons for delay – applicant was out of the country and not able to lodge application in time – applicant’s father was ill after the dismissal – Commission considered whether exceptional circumstances existed [Nulty] – Commission found exceptional circumstances existed – time for lodgement extended – application referred for conciliation. Engelbrecht v Principals Australia Institute t/a Principals Australia Institute Ltd
October 21, 2015
Termination of employment – costs – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – application for permission to appeal from decision at first instance rejecting a costs application made by the appellant – appellant contended Senior Deputy President erred in law and in fact by not granting costs application – Coal & Allied applied – whether in public interest – Full Bench held no error in original decision – decision under appeal discretionary in nature – no error in exercise of discretion – application for permission to appeal dismissed. Appeal by RePipe P/L against decision of O’Callaghan SDP of 11 August 2015 [[2015] FWC 5293] Re: Dunne
October 21, 2015
Fair Work Vice President Michael Lawler might have put his boss Justice Iain Ross offside with his admission on the ABC Four Corners TV programme that he had taped conversations between them. So today Lawler has been sent to Orange to preside over a single unfair dismissal case. Other cases to be heard today include: Shipinki Pty Ltd (Barker), B J Ball Papers (Beavan), Iplex Pipelines Australia Pty Ltd (Wendt), Camp Australia (Ferrie), Australian Postal Corporation (Zoric), Boart Longyear Pty Ltd (Ratajczak), Department of Education and Training (Mahazi), Transdev Melbourne Pty Ltd (Walpola), Marcellin Technical College (Lock), Guru Productions Pty Ltd (Stirk), Chi Kin Krn Ma (Te Rangipuawhe), Bibina (Goldie), Rod Pilon Transport (Hodge) and Pace Farm Pty Ltd (Galea).