ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – Independent Education Union of Australia (IEU) notified of a dispute regarding appointment and/or re-appointment of fixed term staff and whether contract terms accord with the Monash College Proprietary Ltd (Independent Education Foundation Year Teaching Staff) Agreement 2012 – agreement requires teachers be provided with a letter of engagement including a reason for their appointment on a fixed-term – evidence of contracts issued prior to 1 December 2015 not containing any term specifying this – 22 replacement contracts were issued following this date that contained additional wording regarding reasons for appointment – whilst this righted the wrong, the Commission was not convinced that it overcame the earlier incorrectly issued contract – agreement also required that the reason be objectively determined within the constraint of specifically identified activities, where there is no certainty as to the need on an ongoing basis – IEU submitted a determination should be made that the 35 teachers issued with fixed-term contracts in 2016 in fact be considered to have been employed an on-going basis, with a confirmation of such to be provided – NTEIU v University of Wollongong, AIRC applied – held that nothing in agreement would be inconsistent with continuing contracts being imposed in place of the ill-founded fixed-term contracts – decision issued that parties act as though provisions of the agreement had been properly applied – held that if this had this been the case, existing fixed-term staff would have been appointed an on-going basis, with a commencement date of employment being that of any contract contiguous with their current contract – parties to consult on giving effect to this decision. Independent Education Union of Australia v Monash College P/L
July 7, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – employer in liquidation – ss.394, 587 Fair Work Act 2009 – ss.471B, 500(2) Corporations Act 2001 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – application lodged July 2014 – at a pre-arbitration directions conference held mid-December 2014 parties advised that matter had been resolved ‘in principle’ and they would execute deed leading to applicant filing notice of discontinuance – no notice of discontinuance filed – in April 2015 file was administratively closed by Commission – in March 2016 application made by applicant for matter to be set down for arbitration – applicant argued matter has not been resolved, discontinued or withdrawn – respondent in liquidation – respondent made application to dismiss application for want of prosecution and abuse of process – respondent subject to creditors’ voluntary winding up – s.500(2) Corporations Act 2001 considered – Commission is not a Court which is capable of granting leave under s.500 for an action or civil proceedings to be made or continued – s.471B Corporations Act 2001 does not apply to these circumstances – Smith distinguished – Clifford and Craddock considered – found in circumstances of a creditors’ voluntary winding up s.500(2) Corporations Act 2001 precludes Commission from proceeding with application in the absence of a Court granting leave for action to continue – in circumstances inappropriate to determine respondent’s application to dismiss – application stayed – in absence of applicant providing evidence that an application has been made to a Court in the next 30 days application will be dismissed without further notice. Klemm v Penrice Soda Products P/L (in liquidation)
July 7, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – termination of agreement – ss.225, 226 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Griffin Coal Mining Company P/L for the termination of an enterprise agreement after its nominal expiry date – parties bargaining on replacement enterprise agreement to the Griffin Coal (Maintenance) Collective Agreement 2012 (Maintenance Agreement) – employees have voted not to approve the replacement agreement finalised by the bargaining representatives – nominal expiry date of Maintenance Agreement was 26 April 2015 – views of the parties considered – Commission satisfied it would not be contrary to the public interest to terminate the Maintenance Agreement – after 12 months of bargaining and a vote on a proposed replacement agreement, the parties have not been able to reach agreement – termination of the Maintenance Agreement will result in reduced conditions of employment for the employees, however, that is contemplated in the scheme of the FW Act – pursuant to s.226(1) of the FW Act, Commission satisfied that it must terminate the Maintenance Agreement because it is not contrary to the public interest to do so – termination of the Maintenance Agreement will take effect from 10 July 2016. Griffin Coal (Maintenance) Collective Agreement 2012
July 7, 2016
ANTI-BULLYING – bullied at work – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying directed to employer and executive office of the employer – applicant raised a number of complaints including unreasonable work demands, failure to deliver a promised pay advance and contact from the employer at his home – the applicant submitted that the bullying was repeated and at risk of continuing – employer submitted there was no evidence of bullying behaviour and that the actions of the employer and members of the Board constituted reasonable management action – each of the instances of alleged bullying were considered by the Commission – on any objective analysis of the evidence there could be no finding of unreasonable behaviour towards the applicant – therefore the applicant could not be considered a worker who was bullied at work – application dismissed. Samuel v Inner South-West Community Development Organisation Ltd t/a ISWCDO and Anor
July 7, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – company vehicle allocated to applicant involved in single vehicle accident – applicant stood down on full pay pending receipt of police report regarding incident – respondent subsequently contacted applicant and advised it was undertaking own investigation rather than await finalisation of police investigation – applicant terminated with notice following investigation – applicant asserted the keys to the vehicle assigned to him were either lost by him or stolen from him and the vehicle had been taken by someone unknown to him and involved in the crash – applicant asserted termination unjust because he did not damage vehicle, unreasonable because respondent had wrongfully assumed losing keys to vehicle was reason for vehicle being damaged, unfair and harsh as it was disproportionate to offence – respondent submitted dismissal was fair due to applicants reckless lack of care for its property, breaching its policies and creating risk to his safety and that of third parties – respondent asserted that applicant was aware of all allegations against him and was give opportunities to provide his own account of events – Smith and Others considered regarding circumstantial evidence – found material points to applicant being driver at time of accident – Commission satisfied dismissal was defensible or justifiable on an objective analysis of the relevant facts – valid reason for dismissal – found dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Chisholm v Coates Hire Operations P/L t/a Coates Hire
July 7, 2016
ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – protected action ballot – ss.172, 433, 437 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for a protected action ballot order (PABO) – Laing O’Rourke Australia Construction P/L opposed the PABO on the basis that among other things, the ‘Employment Security Clause’ (ESC) was not a permitted matter pursuant to s.172 FW Act and applicant had not been genuinely seeking to reach agreement as required by s.443 – Commission satisfied applicant was genuinely trying to reach an agreement and that ESC was a permitted matter pursuant to s.172 – Commission further satisfied PABO submitted by applicant complied with requirements of s.443 – protected action ballot order made. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union
July 7, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – high income threshold – ss.382, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed under common law contract – annual salary of $160,000 plus 9.5% superannuation – exceeded high income threshold – applicant submitted employment regulated by Hydrocarbons Industry (Upstream) Award 2010 – applicant further submitted he was classified as an operations and processing employee – respondent submitted no classification covered applicant’s position in modern award – whether applicant’s employment covered by modern award – Commission considered it insufficient that some of applicant’s incidental tasks were within classification structure – held applicant’s position could not be described as an operation or processing employee – not necessary to consider classification level – held modern award did not apply to applicant’s position – applicant not protected from unfair dismissal – application dismissed. Simon v ENSCO Australia P/L t/a ESV
July 7, 2016
GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – ss.365, 366 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal – applicant submitted that as he was not provided with anything in writing to confirm his dismissal his application should be considered to have been lodged within 21 days – applicant relied upon reason that he was required to assist with his parents’ and his uncle’s affairs – applicant relied, in part, on representative error to explain why his application was not lodged in time as his solicitor advised him to notify the Commission of a dispute rather than make a general protections application – Commission found applicant had not provided a reasonable explanation for the whole of the delay – having considered factors in s.366(2) of FW Act and drawing on Nulty – Commission found no exceptional circumstances warranting an extension of time – application dismissed. Jones v Motorola Solutions Australia P/L