TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 400A, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – respondent sought an order for all of the costs it incurred in respect to the unfair dismissal application made by the applicant – applicant filed a notice of discontinuance after hearing – Commission found applicant instigated and co-ordinated the transport of alcohol into a dry community and improperly interfered with pilots in their task of flying aircraft – respondent submitted the unfair dismissal application had no reasonable prospects of success – further submitted it should not have been put to the costs of defending its actions and its costs application should be granted – application under s.611 of FW Act – Commission not satisfied, on very fine balance, that the applicant instituted proceedings vexatiously – Church v Eastern Health considered – Commission satisfied it should have been apparent that the application was made without reasonable cause – satisfied that it should have reasonably apparent to the applicant that his application had no reasonable prospect of success – application under s.400A of FW Act – Commission satisfied it was an unreasonable act on the part of the applicant not to admit the conduct – found applicant engaged in an unreasonable omission that caused costs – Commission found grounds under both s.611 and s.400A of the FW Act on which to award costs – costs awarded from 23 March 2016, the date the settlement proposal was put to the applicant. Milner v Marthakal Homelands and Resource Centre Aboriginal Corporation t/a Marthakal Homelands Resource Centre Inc
July 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant dismissed for engaging in inappropriate conversations on the two-way radio during a 12.5-hour night shift and remaining on the two-way radio for extended periods of time during his shift – Commission determined that respondent had valid reason for dismissal – B, C and D v Australian Postal Corporation T/A Australia Post considered – Commission concluded applicant’s dismissal was harsh, but not unjust or unreasonable – dismissal was ‘harsh in its consequences for the personal and economic situation of the employee’ and ‘because it is disproportionate to the gravity of the misconduct in respect of which the employer acted’ [Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd] – respondent contended reinstatement not appropriate as they had lost trust and confidence in applicant – Commission satisfied applicant demonstrated enough self-awareness as to his conduct during the shift to give rise to sufficient confidence that such conduct would not recur if reinstated – reinstatement appropriate – respondent ordered under s.391(2)(a) FW Act to maintain continuity of applicant’s employment. Goodall v Mt Arthur Coal P/L t/a Mt Arthur Coal
July 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – incapacity – inherent requirements – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant terminated for reasons of physical incapacity due to an injury to his left ankle – applicant’s doctor cleared him via certificate as fit to return to work with a restriction on prolonged activity on steep inclines – as a result of receiving this certificate the respondent advised the applicant not to return to work and organised an assessment – as a result of this assessment the respondent determined that the applicant was unfit to carry out the inherent requirements of his role – applicant submitted that respondent did not adequately understand his role so as to correctly interpret this assessment, and that it was reasonable that any restricted work could be reallocated – Commission considered that the applicant’s minor incapacity did not preclude him from carrying out his contractual obligations to the respondent and the inherent requirements of his role – found no valid reason for the dismissal – satisfied the applicant’s dismissal was unfair – reinstatement, maintenance of employment continuity and restoration of lost pay ordered. Billett v West Coast Council
July 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant worked at respondent’s warehouse in Port Adelaide – after finishing work on Friday 29 January 2016 he received an email advising of his redundancy on that day – applicant was to be paid one weeks’ pay to ‘… assist [him] in transitioning to another job’ – whether genuine redundancy – applicant’s role still required at alternate site – applicant not offered alternate role due to performance concerns – respondent failed to consult – Commission found no genuine redundancy – whether respondent complied with the provisions of Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (Code) – difficult to determine whether Code applied due to respondent’s failure to provide evidence of staffing – applicant notified of termination by email after leaving workplace – applicant not warned about performance or provided an opportunity to address concerns – in case it applies, Commission determined Code not complied with – whether dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable – dismissal procedure callous and insensitive – consideration that respondent a family business with no HR expertise given some weight but does not excuse absence of any semblance of proper procedure – payment of one weeks’ notice does not abrogate responsibility to deal fairly with applicant – found dismissal unfair – compensation of $7,846.45 ordered. Gehlken v Office Furniture Direct P/L
July 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed as Aviation Screening Officer (ASO) – dismissed due to misconduct – applicant alleged to have removed manicure kit from surrendered items drawer at screening point and put it into her handbag – applicant did not dispute she took the manicure kit, though contended she did so with the permission of the acting Duty Shift Supervisor (DSS) at the time – respondent submitted applicant argument failed for three reasons – firstly, acting DSS denied permitting applicant to take manicure kit; secondly acting DSS was not on shift at the time; and thirdly, even if acting DSS did make the comment, it could not be interpreted as an instruction or the right for applicant to take the manicure kit – Commission found that CCTV footage did not support evidence applicant placed manicure kit in her bag in front of acting DSS and in view of the other ASO’s around at the time – CCTV indicates applicant looked up prior to placing the manicure kit in her handbag and acting DSS was between 1.5 and 2 metres away from her and none of the other staff at the screening point were paying any attention to what the applicant was doing – Commission found valid reason for dismissal – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Palm v Sydney Night Patrol & Inquiry Co. P/L t/a SNP Security
July 12, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute under the AMWU, CEPU and Simplot Australia P/L National Collective Agreement 2014-2017 (the 2014 Agreement) – Commission considered whether 12-hour shift workers at Kelso site entitled to meal allowance from mid-2006 to 2012 – statutory limits meant the claim could only go back to 2008 – Commission held 2014 Agreement not relevant – potential jurisdictional issues raised – Commission considered dispute turned on interpretation of the AMWU and Simplot Australia P/L National Collective Agreement 2011-2014 (the 2011 Agreement) and the Simplot Australia P/L (National Framework) Certified Agreement 2008 (the 2008 Agreement) – applicant submitted shift workers not entitled to meal allowance because the relevant agreements provided a loaded rostered rate intended to cover monetary entitlements for 12 hour shift workers – further submitted no overtime actually worked by employees and history of the relevant Award and negotiations for the Kelso 12 hour shift arrangement supported this interpretation – AMWU submitted meal allowance included in Kelso 12 hour shift rostered rate or that it is excluded from the Kelso 12 hour agreement, hence employees entitled to meal allowance – Commission applied the principles of Golden Cockerel because of the inadequate drafting in 2008 and 2011 agreements and uncertainty created by the intersection of agreements and incorporated Award – Commission held employees did not work the one and a half hours overtime required to be entitled to meal allowance because 12 hour shifts were ordinary hours of work – further held that even if this consideration was incorrect the evidence surrounding the negotiations for Kelso 12 hour shift arrangements established loaded rate intended to compensate employees for paid meal allowance entitlement – claim for payment of meal allowance dismissed. Simplot Australia P/L v ‘Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union’ known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU)
July 12, 2016
ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – protected action ballot – ss.437, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision at first instance to grant protected action ballot order – grounds of appeal included that respondent advanced substantive claims for non-permitted matters – steps which respondent had taken in relation to negotiations were for sole purpose of securing new enterprise agreement with appellant – respondent was genuinely trying to reach agreement – decision not attended by sufficient doubt such as to warrant appellate review – did not manifest injustice – did not raise any question of general application concerning interpretation or application of s.443(1) of FW Act that would justify granting permission in public interest or on discretionary grounds – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by MMA Offshore Vessel Operations P/L against decision of Watson VP on 17 May 2016 [[2016] FWC 2481] Re: The Maritime Union of Australia
July 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application relief from unfair dismissal – applicant’s employment with respondent terminated – respondent claimed applicant dismissed due to declining relief work requirements – respondent argued that applicant had a poor performance record – applicant claimed his position was advertised after his dismissal, therefore the position was not redundant – Commission considered genuine redundancy – held that no new employees were hired and position was redundant – s.389(1)(a) of FW Act satisfied – agreement stated respondent must provide in writing matters likely to affect employees – respondent did not provide writing to applicant – respondent failed to consult terms of agreement – s.389(1)(b) not satisfied – not genuine redundancy – whether dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable – dismissal not related to conduct so validity, notification, opportunity are neutral factors [UES (Int’l) P/L] – applicant had not realistic opportunity for a support person indicated unfairness – small size of respondent company could favourably mitigate relief – respondent’s lack of exploration of alternative work for applicant indicates unfairness – respondent’s failure to consult agreement indicates harsh, unjust, or unreasonable termination – dismissal unfair – compensation of $2,865.11 less tax ordered. Bayley v Temples (WA) P/L t/a Temples WA