TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s. 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant worked on respondent’s glass cutting line – incident occurred between applicant and production manager where respondent alleged applicant was aggressive – applicant did not receive formal warning over incident as showed remorse – applicant involved in another incident with fellow employee – applicant left workplace after incident – applicant contacted production manager by telephone and hung up on him – applicant subsequently dismissed in telephone call – Commission determined whether alleged conduct took place and whether it constituted valid reason on basis of evidence – Commission unable to form definitive view as to whether conduct attributed to applicant (other than leaving workplace) occurred – Commission not satisfied there was valid reason for dismissal – Commission not satisfied that reason for termination was defensible or justifiable on objective analysis of facts – found dismissal unreasonable – Commission did not consider reinstatement appropriate as would make already fractious relationship untenable – ordered compensation in lieu of reinstatement of $11,250 less tax to be paid 28 days of decision being issued. Edwards v Jeld-Wen Glass Australia P/L t/a Jeld-Wen Glass Australia
August 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant made redundant in August 2015 – claimed similar role advertised in February or March 2016 – subsequently undertook research before lodging unfair dismissal application 230 days out of time – ignorance of statutory time limit not exceptional circumstance [Nulty] – no obligation on employer to inform redundant employee of rights to dispute dismissal – no adequate explanation for failure to lodge application earlier – applicant did not dispute dismissal until lodging application – no undue prejudice to respondent if extension granted – applicant’s submission that respondent failed to consult in accordance with applicable award not without merit – nonetheless to grant extension may result in unreasonable expectation that terminations due to redundancy can be challenged many months following termination – no exceptional circumstances – application dismissed. Dunn v Professional Investment Services P/L a subsidiary of Centrepoint Alliance Ltd t/a Professional Investment Services (PIS)
August 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – employment terminated following restructure – applicant argued it would have been reasonable to redeploy him into another position and failure to do so meant dismissal was not genuine redundancy – respondent consulted with applicant during restructure – respondent considered applicant for redeployment but applicant did not have necessary skill set and/or qualifications for available roles and was unable to relocate – four positions jointly identified by parties narrowed to two positions of Asset Engineer and Business Engagement role – Commission found gaps in applicant’s experience relative to Asset Engineer requirements could not be overcome with training – Commission found retraining would not enable applicant to fulfil requirement for higher managerial level for Business Engagement role – Commission satisfied applicant was kept informed of restructure – held dismissal was genuine redundancy – application dismissed. Jewell v Broadspectrum P/L
August 29, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute between union and respondent employer under terms of Alcoa World Alumina Australia WA Operations AWU Enterprise Agreement 2014 (Agreement) – question to be determined whether respondent contravened clause 19(a) of Agreement when issued written warning to two convenors working within respondent’s mining operations – in 2013 parties recorded agreement as to types of shorts that would be made available to employees under the WA Mining Dress Policy (Policy) – convenors required to comply with Policy – union convenors disagreed with requirement for compliance – respondent made arrangements for implementation of Policy in March 2015 – employees notified compliance mandatory at this time – two convenors continued to wear clothing which was non-compliant after March 2015 – written warnings issued by respondent to convenors in April and November 2015 – when respondent issued written warnings to two convenors in November 2015 it breached requirement to observe status quo that applied from time respondent first raised dispute in August 2015 – requirement to observe status quo under clause 19(a) of Agreement – status quo normal conditions or arrangements in existence immediately prior to cause of dispute arising – Commission held this comprised of three elements – firstly, Policy had been implemented and on its face applied to all employees; secondly, convenors continued to wear clothing which did not comply with Policy; thirdly, respondent refrained from applying disciplinary consequences to two employees for non-compliance – found respondent’s acts of issuing written warnings to two convenors in November 2015 for non-compliance with Policy was failure to observe status quo – held contravention of clause 19 (b) of Agreement. Australian Workers’ Union v Alcoa of Australia Limited t/a Alcoa World Alumina Australia
August 29, 2016
GENERAL PROTECTIONS – jurisdiction – ss.14, 365 Fair Work Act 2009 – s.692(2) Queensland Industrial Relations Act 1999 – application for Commission to deal with a breach of general protections involving dismissal – applicant submitted she was dismissed for complaining about an unsafe work environment – respondent submitted Commission lacked jurisdiction to deal with application because it was not a national system employer – respondent falls within exclusions under s. 14 FW Act and therefore not a national system employer – s.692(2) Industrial Relations Act (Queensland) 1999 declares respondent not to be a national system employee – Commission satisfied respondent not a national system employee and that it lacks jurisdiction to deal with application – application dismissed. Millen v Brisbane City Council
August 29, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – confidentiality – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for order to stop bullying – decision deals with application by the s.789FC applicants for confidentiality orders – principal application under s.789FC – company of employees making s.789FC application involved in industrial dispute with union relating to terms and conditions of employment of persons employed by company – conduct about which complaint made in principal application involves allegations about conduct or behaviour of persons who are participating in picket outside work site entrance – applicants do not wish to be identified for reasons such as concerns relating to escalation of conduct about which they complain is directed towards them – Commission accepts concerns genuinely held and risk of escalation not merely theoretical – Commission persuaded an order protecting applicants’ anonymity in regards to their name and address should be made – orders sought by applicants would unduly restrict capacity of legal representatives of other parties to this proceeding – Commission considers order made must appropriately balance applicants’ concerns and interest of other parties to proceedings – applicants must advise Commission in light of order made whether they are prepared to participate in proceedings as applicants and give evidence before Commission – Commission will give consideration to interim order relating to conduct after advice from applicants received – order issued. Worker A, Worker B, Worker C, Worker D and Worker E
August 29, 2016
ANTI-BULLYING – reasonable management action – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – Commission satisfied application valid – no doubt alleged incidents over three years took place – whether some or all incidents constitute actual bullying to justify making of order – whether incidents were reasonable management action carried out in reasonable manner – no specific number of incidents required for the behaviour to represent ‘repeatedly’ behaving unreasonably, nor that the same specific behaviour be repeated [GC] – must be repeated unreasonable behaviour by the individual or individuals toward the applicant worker – ‘unreasonable’ is an objective assessment – test is whether management action is reasonable not whether it could have been more reasonable – applicant’s conviction that she has been bullied is genuinely held by her – applicant had limited understanding of what bullying is – her belief was based on what she felt – responses to emails about workload were courteous, co-operative and even friendly – emails not aggressive – Commission found applicant did not accept her manager’s authority and wanted to run her own race – no corroborating evidence of applicant being bullied at team meetings – manager may have been direct and forceful on occasions – action does not amount to bullying – despite failure to substantiate claims in investigation, employer still arranged mediation and counselling – Commission satisfied investigations sound, appropriate and reasonable – Commission of view applicant acted unreasonably – applicant argumentative and defiant as a witness, and only sought to answer questions which suited her case – manager’s evidence was truthful and believable – medical evidence does not support a causal link between how applicant felt and managers actions toward her – application dismissed. Cao
August 29, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – termination of agreement – ss.313, 590(2)(c) Fair Work Act 2009 – interlocutory decision related to two applications by LCR Group P/L (LCR) to terminate LCR Group P/L/CFMEU Collective Agreement 2012 – 2016 and LCR Group and CFMEU Union Collective Agreement 2011 – 2015 (the agreements) – submissions sought from the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) – CFMEU filed two applications for Orders for production of documents seeking documents relating to the sale of assets and the transfer of employment of any of LCR’s employees who were covered by the agreements within a three month period of the selling of the assets – LCR objected on the basis that the termination of the agreements in question have no bearing on the instrument that was transferred to the new owner – LCR submitted that the termination of the agreements has no implication for a transferable instrument that applies to a new owner, as there is no continuing nexus with the agreement that covered the old employer and its employees – Commission satisfied that the effect of a transfer of business upon an enterprise agreement is to widen the coverage of the instrument to extend to the new employer and the transferring employees, preserving the same coverage rules in the process – Commission satisfied that this construction supports the relevance of the items sought in the CFMEU applications – CFMEU asked to reformat applications in light of decision. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v LCR Group P/L