NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute under Aurizon Train Crew and Transport Operations Enterprise Agreement 2015 – employees affected by dispute are Transport Operators working for Aurizon (Transport Operators were previously known as ‘Shunters’ and are still referred to as such), at the rail depot at Pring, on the outskirts of Bowen in North Queensland – these employees do not work outside of the rail yard and are covered by the Transport Operations Stream clauses of the Agreement – applicant claimed that respondent’s use of the Agreement provisions to have additional duties undertaken, for no additional payment, was not agreed during the recent negotiations and was not permitted under the Agreement – claim that these employees are entitled to the Higher Grade Allowance (in clause 35) for time undertaking these new duties – Interim Decision was released in this matter following a hearing – respondent argued the combination of number of clauses provided basis for duties to be undertaken with no additional payment – stated the classification tasks and clauses of the Agreement allowed them to direct employees to perform those duties – applicant stated there was no clear indication from negotiations that application of new Agreement was going to be used in this way, to assign these additional duties, within the current pay range – no submissions were filed on a work value claim – applicant sought for affected employees to be paid at the higher duties rate of $6.4428 per hour – submitted that the disagreement was that Shunters should not undertake training to perform the start-up, relinking and shutting down of a locomotive because that training was not required to perform the role for which they were employed – respondent submitted that the intention in this respect, was to ensure employees were trained, as well as competent, to perform any new tasks which they might be required to perform as part of their employment – further submitted that descriptions of tasks and functions were not exclusive – lists of indicative tasks and functions were largely taken from previous agreement – Commission concluded that additional competencies did not fall within the scope of the role for which employees were employed – they should not be compensated for the period of time that they carried out these tasks as not all of the tasks commensurate with the High Grade allowance – employees should not be compensated for the period of time they performed the tasks based on the work value of the tasks as this was not pursued by the applicant – employees should not be back paid for the period of time that they had been carrying out the tasks as this was also not sought by the applicant – the claimed remuneration of the Higher Grade allowance was not applicable to the subset of duties sought to be undertaken – the extra duties do not fall within their classification and therefore the direction was not in accordance with the applicable Agreement provisions. Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union v Aurizon Operations Ltd

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as senior network engineer from December 2015 until dismissal on 10 October 2016 – applicant required to work in the Melbourne office at normal office hours when not at country sites – respondent submitted applicant repeatedly failed to attend the office at normal office hours except when working at country sites and complete time sheets on time and fully – applicant conceded he was rarely in the office despite clear instruction – applicant further failed to report he had lost his licence for a six month period to his direct manager – applicant was in receipt of car allowance during period he was legally unable to drive – respondent prepared final warning notice – applicant signed to acknowledge receipt of notice on 6 October 2016 – Commission noted final warning letter was poorly drafted and confusing – satisfied its purpose was to put applicant on notice and failure to attend the office or complete timesheets could lead to dismissal – applicant dismissed by phone call on 10 October 2016 – applicant not given adequate opportunity to respond in phone call – Commission noted this factor usually stands in favour of finding a dismissal was unfair – found this was an unusual case – not satisfied in this case this factor was sufficient to make the termination unfair based on a number of factors – applicant’s manager based in Bendigo and applicant based in Melbourne – accepted telephone was most effective way to communicate – Commission satisfied attendance at the office during normal office hours when not required in the country and timely completion of time sheets were reasonable instructions – accepted applicant repeatedly defied clear instructions – applicant received final warning only two working days prior to phone call – found dismissal was fair – dismissal was not a disproportionate response to the defiance of reasonable management directions – application dismissed. Nourfadi v Viatek Technology P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent argued that applicant was either not dismissed at the initiative of the respondent, or was dismissed in accordance with the small business fair dismissal code – applicant had heated meeting with manager in which applicant was aggressive and abusive and told the respondent that he was resigning before leaving – applicant returned to work the next working and maintained that he had not resigned – Commission held that where an employee unambiguously communicates their intention to resign, the employer is not required to enquire further [Ngo] – held that the applicant, by his statements, did unambiguously communicate their intention to resign – application dismissed. Tan v Vital Packaging

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – AWU filed application to deal with a dispute in relation to introduction of Trade Operator Model (TOM) into the Slabmaking Department at Port Kembla steelworks – Steel Treatment Department (Steel Department) and Shift Maintenance Department sit within Slabmaking Department – BlueScope decided to reduce the number of Operators by 6 in Steel Department – reduction to require tradespersons from the Shift Maintenance Department and shift staff employees to undertake Grade 3 Operator tasks during periods of peak workload in Steel Treatment Department – AMWU raised threshold issue that introduction of TOM a ‘significant change’ as defined by s.35.2.2(c) of the BlueScope Steel Port Kembla Steelworks Agreement 2015 (Agreement) – as significant change, consultation provisions in clause 35.2.3 of Agreement required to be followed – not in dispute that maintenance employees and Unions had not been consulted in accordance with clause 35.2.3 – BlueScope argued introduction of TOM did not result in significant change for maintenance employees – Commission considered AWU, CEPU & AMWU v BlueScope in which BlueScope submitted that introduction of TOM a significant change in other departments and consulted with unions (Trade Operator Decision) – Commission found that requiring maintenance employees to learn and utilise new skills for at least 20% of their hours of work created a substantial change to the skills of a tradesperson working in Slabmaking Department – change to substantially alter the constitution of Slabmaking Department – disingenuous for BlueScope to make contrary submission to that made in Trade Operator Decision – found maintenance employees and unions entitled to be consulted pursuant to clause 35.2.3 of Agreement – proposal to introduce TOM into Slabmaking Department failed to satisfy threshold question raised by AMWU – found BlueScope did not comply with introduction of change processes in clause 35.2.3 of Agreement – consultation not fair, comprehensive or genuine – BlueScope required to recommence consultation in relation to proposal. The Australian Workers’ Union – New South Wales Branch and Anor v BlueScope Steel (AIS) Port Kembla

ANTI-BULLYING – repeated behaviour – reasonable management action – ss.789FC, 789FD Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – applicant worked as casual food employee and bar attendant at Park Beach Bowling Club Limited (the Club) – made application for order to stop bullying against CEO and Administration and Events Manager as persons she alleged engaged in bullying behaviour – applicant also sought order that warning issued to her by Club on 18 October 2016 be withdrawn or retracted – Commission considered test for what constitutes bullying under FW Act – test is objective – behaviour is unreasonable if a reasonable person, having regard to the circumstances, may consider it to be unreasonable – apparent from the reference to ‘repeatedly’ in s.789FD(1) of the FW Act that a one-off incident will not be a sufficient basis for the making of an application to the Commission [Re SB] – provided there is more than one occurrence, there is no specific number of incidents required to meet the condition of ‘repeated’ behaviour, nor does the same specific behaviour have to be repeated [GC] – necessary to also undertake objective assessment of action to determine whether action constitutes reasonable management action [Re SB] – allegations of bullying behaviour were limited to four instances – first instance of alleged bullying related to the Club’s investigation into complaints made by employees against applicant – second instance related to an allegation that applicant was spoken to for being rude and insubordinate towards Bar Coordinator – third instance related to an alleged failure to conduct an investigation into a matter involving applicant in a fair and equitable manner – fourth instance concerned a complaint made by applicant against Bar Coordinator – evidence was given in proceedings in relation to some of the ways in which applicant refused to obey directions given to her by supervisors and managers at work – Club accepted that warning letter dated 18 October 2016 was not appropriate and was unreasonable disciplinary measure – Commission found that warning letter issued to applicant by Club Chairman was unreasonable behaviour and was not reasonable management action carried out in reasonable manner – having considered other allegations by the applicant, Commission not satisfied there had been any repeat of any unreasonable behaviour towards applicant by individual or group of individuals at work – Commission found applicant had not been bullied at work within s.789FD – application dismissed. Brown v Park Beach Bowling Club Limited v Ors

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute under Freightliner Australia Coal Haulage P/L Enterprise Agreement 2015 about whether ‘advice periods’ apply in circumstances where employer seeks to advance (by up to two hours) or delay (by up to four hours) the start of an employee’s shift – union contended that respondent must notify employees within the ‘advice period’ set out in agreement – employer contended ‘advice periods’ do not apply in these circumstances – principles of Golden Cockerel apply – two further principles relevant: conduct of parties after an industrial instrument is mad cannot be used to aid interpretation of that instrument [Essential Energy]; guidance as to the construction of industrial instruments may also be obtained by reference to principles which courts apply to the construction of commercial contracts [Linfox Australia] – right of employer to adjust the commencement time of a shift not contingent upon the giving of notice within the ‘advice periods’ – construction of agreement in manner contended for by employer preferred. Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union v Freightliner Australia Coal Haulage P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as diesel fitter at Peak Downs Mine -alleged to have not complied with safe work instructions and rules and placed himself at an unacceptable level of risk on 22 March 2016 – applicant suspended with pay from the date of the incident – response to ‘show cause’ letter not discussed – dismissed 3 May 2016 – applicant submitted he had acted in accordance with training provided to him and in a manner known to staff and accepted – denied acting contrary to his obligations – submitted no valid reason for dismissal and procedural inadequacies – sought reinstatement – respondent submitted it should have been clear to applicant that breach of any safety-related policy might result in discipline or termination – submitted that if any procedural deficiencies found, dismissal still justified [Byrne] – contended reinstatement inappropriate due to loss of faith in applicant’s ability to work safely – Commission found a valid reason for dismissal – held dismissal unreasonable due to lack of procedural fairness – found dismissal unjust because decision to terminate based on allegations not put to the applicant – remedy – Commission held applicant had unsatisfactory regard for workplace risk and poor attitude towards safety – satisfied reinstatement inappropriate – compensation – applicant had secured other employment – Sprigg applied – four months’ compensation less lieu of notice, other earnings and 30% deduction for misconduct – total compensation of $25,448.98 plus 9.5% superannuation, less tax – order issued. Crawford v BHP Coal P/L

CASE PROCEDURES – costs – ss.611, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – Commission issued decision concerning an application under s.739 of FW Act – Commission decided that the relevant provisions of the Southern Air (Tas) P/L Enterprise Agreement 2015 (Agreement) set out comprehensively the operation of rostered days off (RDO) and entitlements of employees when on various forms of leave, in particular that those provisions do not provide for the accrual of a credit towards RDOs when on paid leave [[2016] FWC 7266] – Southern Air (Tas) P/L applied for a costs order under s.611 – submitted application was made without reasonable cause – further submitted alternative of no reasonable prospects of success – Kanan considered – CEPU submitted that because the Commission rejected its arguments it does not follow that application was made without reasonable cause – further submitted that threshold required for Commission to order costs was not reached – costs respondent relied on Wodonga Rural Council v Lewis and submitted s.611(2)(b) was not enlivened – Keep v Performance Automobiles and Deane v Paper Australia considered – not satisfied that it should have been apparent that the CEPU had no reasonable prospects of success or that originating application was made without reasonable cause – application for costs dismissed. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Southern Air (Tas) P/L