NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.394, 396 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed by respondent from March 2011 to December 2016 – respondent objected to application on basis that redundancy was genuine – applicant employed as Senior Siebel Configurator involved in customising and developing Siebel software for LINX project as part of broader business initiative – notified in July 2016 that project funding withdrawn immediately – review of impact of funding of LINX project in October 2016 resulted in Melbourne-based role being made redundant – applicant informed on 3 November 2016 that his position was redundant and if redeployment not suitable employment would cease on 1 December 2016 – respondent submitted that applicant was specifically involved in customising software not used by respondent anywhere else – applicant submitted that respondent replaced him with consultant whose contract was extended following applicant’s dismissal – respondent submitted that work assigned to consultant was different to applicant’s and required skills he did not possess – Commission satisfied role no longer required to be performed because of changes to operational requirements – determined applicant’s redundancy to be genuine – applicant submitted that respondent failed to consult in accordance with Banking, Finance and Insurance Award 2010 – respondent submitted that applicant was not subject to operation of that award by reason of guarantee of annual earnings – submitted that despite this consultation occurred team-wide then more with personal discussions – Commission satisfied that applicant covered by award but that award does not apply as applicant exceeded high income threshold – satisfied that respondent did consult but did not need to consult in accordance with award – applicant submitted he could have been redeployed – respondent submitted that they made attempts to find suitable alternative roles within bank – Commission satisfied that respondent made genuine attempts to find alternative employment opportunities for applicant – found that dismissal falls within genuine redundancy – dismissal not unfair – application dismissed. Konakalla v Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – jurisdiction – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute under the Healthy Snacks Australia Pty Ltd and National Union of Workers Collective Agreement 2013 – NUW sought ‘declaration’ that certain redundancy entitlements apply to former employees of Healthy Snacks Australia P/L (Healthy Snacks) – alleged dispute about effect of undertaking under s.190 FW Act on terms in Agreement dealing with redundancy pay entitlements – at conference Commission expressed preliminary view that it had no jurisdiction to deal with matter – s.739 confers jurisdiction on Commission to deal with disputes involving employees who are employed at time dispute lodged, even if employment relationship subsequently ends [Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Broadspectrum Australia] – position less clear if employment has come to an end before dispute arose – alleged dispute in matter arose approximately six weeks after employment of each affected employee came to end – Healthy Snacks under administration and had been for some time – Commission found at time dispute arose no employee covered by Agreement – no jurisdiction to deal with dispute – recovery of entitlements under Agreement is a separate matter for which remedy exists in another jurisdiction – application dismissed. National Union of Workers v Healthy Snacks Australia P/L (Administrators Appointed)

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – ss.383, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant did not detail commencement date with respondent but advised dismissal occurred on 6 April 2017 – respondent submitted that applicant commenced employment on 10 October 2016 and raised jurisdictional objection on basis that applicant had not met minimum employment period of six months – applicant initially engaged as Customer Service Coordinator at the respondent’s Perth office through labour provider – applicant expected employment by respondent soon thereafter – applicant had discussions with Head of Business Development about being directly employed by respondent as Account Manager – number of draft contracts of employment were exchanged and applicant persuaded respondent to delete obligation to complete probationary period – applicant commenced employment with respondent as Account Manager on 10 October 2016 – found applicant’s service with respondent was insufficient to meet the minimum employment period – found that transfer of business had not occurred between labour provider and respondent – found applicant not protected from unfair dismissal – application dismissed. Paterson v Clariant Australia P/L t/a Clariant

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.387, 394 Fair Work Act – dismissal after incident with co-workers – applicant did not believe that he had done anything wrong – applicant previously received warnings on variety of issues during course – found applicant’s conduct towards co-workers was breach of respondent’s Workplace Bullying and Harassment Standard and Employee Performance and Behaviour Code – constituted valid reasons for termination – Byrne and Frew applied – termination not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Larcombe v Bis Industries

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – uncontested – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant serviced refrigerators and air-conditioning units – dismissal occurred after allegation that applicant was seen working for himself for cash while employed by respondent – applicant argued he was helping friend repair pool fence at relevant time – multiple attempts were made by Commission to notify respondent of proceedings by way of emails, letters and telephone calls – Commission was satisfied respondent was aware of application and had ample opportunity to respond, however had chosen not to do so – on that basis Commission treated application as uncontested – respondent was found not to have complied with Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – Commission could not be satisfied respondent believed on reasonable grounds that applicant’s conduct was ‘sufficiently serious to justify immediate dismissal’ – if dismissal could have been regarded as with notice, applicant had not been warned, given an opportunity to respond, nor given a valid reason as to why his employment was at risk – Commission accepted that applicant had not done a cash job and found no valid reason for termination – Service Manager and Managing Director had notified applicant of reason for termination, but each accused the other of witnessing alleged conduct and being decision maker – applicant was denied procedural fairness – dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement inappropriate – in calculating compensation Commission applied Sprigg formula and deducted $10,000 earned by applicant in own business since dismissal – Commission ordered compensation of $19,640 gross taxed, plus 9.5% superannuation. Antonarakis v Logan City Electrical Service Division P/L

Fifty-three unfair dismissal/employment breach assertions need to be cleared up by the Fair Work Commission. The full list is: Blake Life Pty Ltd (Wales), Currency Select Pty Ltd (Woods), Fergrove Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd (Ji), Clark Equipment Sales Pty Ltd & Roche (Lennon), Australian Energy Market Commission (Tran), Menzies International (Australia) Pty Ltd (Peters), AME Mineral Economics Pty Ltd (Scott-King), Atlantic Brands Pty Limited (Wu), The Information Management Group Pty Ltd (Clarke), Craig Mostyn Group Food & Agribusiness (Malho), Building Supplies WA (Stanton), Baker Hughes Australia Pty Limited (Manescu), Mario and Clara Enterprises Pty Ltd and Morgan Trading Pty Ltd (Duddington), Town of Victoria Park (Wilson), Cash Converters Pty Ltd (Roberts), Ace Traffic Control (Hunter), BHP Billiton Group (Johnson), St Louis CDC (Pearse), Garry Crick’s (Nambour) Pty Ltd as The Trustee for Crick Unit Trust (Parker), Onterran Ltd (Fan), Pivot Way Pty Ltd (O’Mara, Tottenham), QARC Pty Ltd (Tavita), Stanwell Corporation Limited (Clegg), Oolong Aboriginal Corporation (Longbottom), Woolworths Limited (Guillemain), ISS Facility Services Australia Ltd (Baltas), Swinburne University of Technology (Nickson), Australian Electoral Commission (Inglis), Solar Station Alpha Pty Ltd (von Erkel), ActewAGL (Crane), Securecorp Pty Ltd (Balkan), Kmercial (Di Gioacchino), Desago Real Estate Pty Ltd (Stevenson), Carter Holt Harvey Woodproducts Australia Pty Ltd (Akers), Edith Cowan University (Rogers), Paw Boy Pty Ltd (Solway), Let’s Play Centre (Criddle), Mid West Ports Authority (Drohan), Tox Free Australia Pty Ltd (Carr), Iron Bay Pty Ltd (Seitz), The GEO Group Australia Pty Ltd (Patel, Reihana), The GEO Group (Reilly), Argentis Systems Pty Ltd (Ujlaki), New Horizons (Aust) Ltd (O’Connor), OCS Services (Mathema), Mid West Ports Authority (Drohan), TSA (Jackson), Red Dog Construction & Developments & Elliott Property Group (Hart), Telstra Corporation Limited (Weler), Starlight Group Pty Ltd (Goldsmith).

The Fair Work Commission will hear a list of twenty-nine applications today. The full list is: SRG Corporate (Australia) Pty Ltd (McCarthy), The Uniting Church in Australia Property Trust (Q.) (Copeland), Margiu Pty Ltd (Whiting), John Holland Pty Ltd (JHPL), Australian Careers College (Osman), Toll Holdings Pty Ltd (Foley), AVJennings Holdings Limited (Dokoza), Eureka Operation Pty Ltd (Garg), Telstra (Ghazi), Vision Australia Ltd & Franco (Wilkinson), Central Bayside Community Health Services Limited (Bartlett), Tweed River Agricultural Society Ltd (Stranger), Ramsey Health Care Australia Pty Ltd (Hook), Pilbara Iron Company (Services) Pty Ltd (Moham & Macaulay), Marine Manning Services Pty Ltd (Gosling, Gracie, Stewart), Rio Tinto Limited (Baxter), Morris Corporation (Aust) Pty Ltd (Jaclyn), Parabellum International Pty Ltd (Bolton), Illawarra Coal Holdings Pty Limited (Gosek), St Vincent De Paul Society (Campbell), Queensland Property Investments Pty Limited (Marangon), Clancy Automotive Pty Ltd (Davies), NSW Trains (De Giusti), Amber Aviation Pty Ltd (Agarev), Romeo’s Retail Group (Bury), Monroe Springs (Australia) Pty Ltd and Monroe Australia Pty Ltd and Walker Australia Pty Ltd (Graham), Rexel Holdings Australia (Sickerdick).

Twenty-two unfair dismissal/contract breach applications are due to be heard by the Fair Work Commission. The current list includes: Pine Design Holdings Pty Ltd (Perriman), Barada Barna Aboriginal Corporation (Dargan, Roos), SRG Corporate (Australia) Pty Ltd (McCarthy), Windolf Farms Pty Ltd (Sippel), Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (Higgins), Queensland Bulk Water Supply Authority (Mcpherson), QBar Darwin Pty Ltd (Coffey), Eureka Operation Pty Ltd (Garg), Neibo Real Estate Pty Ltd (Carlin-Smith), Fitzgerald PD Pty Ltd (Evans), SSAA Victoria (Schefferie), Northwest Supermarkets Pty Ltd (Johnson), Securecorp Pty Ltd (Balkan), Western Power (Singh), Boekeman Machinery (WA) Pty Ltd (Thompson), PAC Perth Pty Ltd (Stoney), Queensland Property Investments Pty Limited (Marangon), O’Brien Glass (McMaugh), Blooms the Chemist Management Services (Cameron), Elegant Lashes Pty Ltd (Salgueiro), Spotless Facilities Services Pty Ltd (Hambridge).