NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed 8 December 2016 following investigation into allegations of misconduct – misconduct referred to as ‘scavenging’ – applicant commenced employment with respondent as a weighbridge operator in November 2014 on a casual basis – on 14 November 2016 a machine operator reported a verbal altercation with the applicant – it was alleged in the operator’s compliant that the applicant had scavenged items stored onsite then removed them from site without authorisation – following the compliant respondent conducted an investigation into the allegations – on 23 November 2016 the applicant attended a meeting with representatives of the respondent – at conclusion of meeting applicant was suspended from duties on full pay to allow respondent complete an investigation – at further meeting on 29 November 2016 applicant was given show cause letter in relation to the allegations – on 8 December 2016 applicant was dismissed for misconduct with immediate effect – Commission found applicant had engaged in unauthorised removal of materials from the site, including electronic waste and scrap metal – applicant’s actions were unsafe and completely inappropriate – found respondent properly conducted the investigation and it was reasonable to discipline applicant for misconduct in breach of a lawful and reasonable policy – found applicant was not singled out or otherwise treated different for scavenging – Commission found applicant was notified of valid reason for dismissal before decision was made – satisfied applicant had a number of opportunities to respond to the allegations – applicant engaged in prohibited conduct which justified disciplinary action – found dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Adams v SUEZ Recycling & Recovery (No.1) P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent argued dismissal was case of genuine redundancy – applicant held the position of ‘Relief Project Manager’ however had not been rostered to work since September 2016 – employed within one of the respondent’s ‘relief pools’, workgroups designed to backfill positions at various worksites during periods of employee absence – made redundant on 24 March 2017 as the result of a restructure that saw relief pools outsourced to an external labour hire company – Commission satisfied applicant’s job was no longer required to be performed by anyone – found no identified position within the respondent’s operation, or its associated entities’ enterprises where it would have been reasonable to redeploy applicant – satisfied the termination of the applicant’s employment was a case of genuine redundancy – however it would have been reasonable for the respondent to notify the applicant of the redundancy at an earlier date and commence exploring redeployment opportunities at that time – application dismissed. Hallam v Sodexo Remote Sites Australia P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.54, 206, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute about proper application of clause concerning minimum hourly rates in B-d Farm Paris Creek P/L Employee Collective Workplace Agreement 2009 (Agreement) – clause stated minimum hourly rates specified would be adjusted by three per cent annually – whether under terms of Agreement the adjustment continued beyond nominal expiry date – Agreement expired three years ago – parties sought assistance of Commission under Agreement – doubt about capacity of Commission to make binding determination – parties requested Commission issue public assessment – applicant claimed annual adjustment only applied to nominal life of Agreement – claimed was inverse to object in s.171(a) for an enterprise agreement to continue to apply increases following nominal expiry where Act provides mechanism in s.206 to uphold safety net [Catalina Country Club] as ‘could confer an unreasonable windfall’ – respondent claimed three per cent annual adjustment should continue as long as Agreement remains in place – Commission considered Full Bench approach to construction of enterprise agreement [AMWU v Berri] – consideration involves ordinary and natural meaning of terms of clause read in context – no express or implied limit on application of clause – Agreement remains in operation under terms of s.54 of FW Act – all terms of Agreement remained enforceable and binding – Commission distinguished case from Catalina where wage adjustments were limited to nominal life – in Catalina issue about whether wage adjustments continued to apply was collateral to potential impact of agreement termination – Commission accepted bargaining for agreement generally involves wage outcomes for nominal life – each agreement must be considered on own terms to discern objective intention – given terms of agreement reasonable that full terms of agreement continue to apply until ceases to operate – wage adjustment not limited to nominal life – accepted s.206 applies and base rates in Agreement cannot be less than award – does not discern objective intention in Act or Agreement that s.206 means clause should not apply as agreed – clause continued to operate and apply – recommended applicant reconsider and calculate proper rates under Agreement – underpayment of entitlements should be rectified – parties commence to negotiate new agreement. B-d Farm Paris Creek P/L v Johnson

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant made application for resolution of dispute under dispute resolution term within Victorian Catholic Education Multi Enterprise Agreement 2013 (the Agreement) – applicant is classified under the Agreement as Level ES 4 employee – applicant considered this to be one grade too low given his duties and demonstrated competencies and sought relief to be reclassified and paid the correct salary as per the Agreement Level ES5.1 – applicant submitted that changes to his role between 2010 and 2017 were significant and his role had grown beyond Level ES 4 – applicant further submitted that he was engaged in development and deployment of information technology strategy which was key feature of Level ES 5 – applicant also submitted that with reference to criterion within descriptors for Level ES 5 that role is featured with leadership and management of significant functional element of large school – respondent submitted that applicant was not undertaking the work of Level ES 5 and did not have management responsibility for its Information Communication and Technology (ICT) function – respondent further submitted that applicant managed day-to-day operational requirements of ICT function but did not have leadership and management responsibility – found work described by applicant was broadly consistent with competencies set out in General Work Description for Level ES 4 however those features of competency do not amount to level described within General Work Description for Level ES 5 – unable to make finding that applicant’s job was to ‘lead and manage a significant functional element’ – applicant did not demonstrate that work he was undertaking was aligned with judgement, independence and problem-solving descriptors of Level ES 5 – found circumstance of applicant’s supervision fits Level ES 5 descriptor but is probably circumstances arisen by default or lack of management rather than conscious decision making – found that applicant was not working at level expected of Supervision for Level ES 5 – nothing before Commission formally identifying respondent’s requirements in relation to qualifications and experience nor is there sufficient evidence that applicant is insufficiently qualified or experienced to be classified at Level ES 5 – no findings made in respect of this aspect of the descriptors therefore qualifications and experience are neutral consideration – found applicant is performing duties consistent with, and not significantly beyond, Level ES 4 defined ‘typical duties’ – unable to make finding that applicant is working at ES 5 level – application dismissed. Murphy v Mercy Education Limited t/a Sacred Heart College, Kyneton

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – ss.186, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission approved the SESLS Industrial P/L Employee Black Coal Mining Industry Enterprise Agreement 2017 – agreement provided for casual employment where there is no provision in award – three grounds of appeal: that the Commission erred in failing to afford the appellant procedural fairness; Commission erred in finding that the Agreement satisfied provisions in s.186 of the FW Act; Commission erred in being satisfied the Agreement met the Better Off Overall Test (BOOT) and therefore erred in approving the agreement – Full Bench found that no practical injustice arose and took into account that the appellant is a sophisticated organisation and therefore was not denied an opportunity to develop its argument of whether it should be heard – the appellant’s concern about the agreement was that it allowed for the employment of production and engineering employees on a casual basis, whereas the Black Coal Mining Industry Award 2010 does not – Full Bench found that the Commission did not err in its application of the BOOT or decision to approve the agreement – the agreement incorporates the award, and guarantees employees will receive 1% more remuneration they would receive under the award – although casual engagement of production and engineering employees is not permitted under the award, it is under the agreement and affords a 25% loading – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Lee C of 28 April 2017 [[2017] FWCA 2308] Re: SESLS Industrial P/L

The Fair Work Commission will hear 23 applicants covering unfair dismissal/employment disputes today. The full list is: QantasLink (Cook), Emirates Leisure Retail (Australia) Pty Ltd (Arulchelvam, Nguyen, Park), Command IT Pty Ltd (Briffa), Brisbane Container Terminals Pty Ltd (Carnegie), Real Pet Food Company (Kemp), Independence Australia (Legge), Epworth Foundation (Naicker), Victoria International Container Terminal Limited (Lunt, Niccoli), MECWA (Camilleri), Grandbridge Limited (Wiburd), Childcare Management Service Pty Ltd (Kaul), Peoplesmove Pty Ltd (Wright), Bluestone Mines Tasmania Joint Venture Pty Ltd (Goodsell), Broome Tourist Bureau (Linton), Iron Bay Pty Ltd (Seitz), Sydney Trains (Robinson), Amber Traffic Design Group Pty Ltd (Chadwick), Target Australia Pty Ltd (Drosd), Department of Human Services (O’Connell), National Australia Bank Pty Ltd (McAvaney).

An 18 application caseload won’t overtly trouble a crowded bench of Fair Work Commissioners today. The full list is: Australia Personnel Global Pty Ltd (Phuaprasert), Teys Australia Central Queensland Pty Ltd (Rodrigues), Churchill Management Pty Ltd (Athanates), QARC Pty Ltd (Tavita), Barcoo Retirement Village Incorporated (Hinds), SMW (Laidlaw), William Angliss Institute (Baker), Carter Holt Harvey Woodproducts Australia Pty Ltd (Akers), Pharmacy World Pty Ltd (Cook), Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Ltd (Martin), Zoological Parks and Gardens Board (Borg), New Horizons (Aust) Ltd (O’Connor), BlueScope Steel (AIS) Port Kembla (Antony), Sydney Trains (Robinson), San Churros (Richings), Miele Australia Pty Ltd (Weninger), On Site Fleet Wash Pty Ltd (Loxton), Viterra Operations Pty Ltd (Shearing).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full bench – appellant was employed by CrimTrac since September 2013 and employment was terminated by respondent on 30 November 2016 following a performance improvement process – Commission at first instance found the process undertaken by respondent was thorough and fair and there was a valid reason for dismissal – appellant sought permission to appeal on 12 grounds – on related grounds, appellant contended that Commission erred in not properly considering the effect of CrimTrac’s merge with the Australian Crime Commission in July 2016 on his Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) – contended the PIP should have been modified and he was not properly informed of its ongoing application following the merger – that ‘close supervision’ should have been provided to him as required under the new Australian Crime Commission Enterprise Agreement 2011-2014 which replaced CrimTrac’s agreement – appellant raised issues with the Commission’s consideration of evidence, including that those reviewing the PIP were not subject matter experts – appellant alleged that he was denied opportunity for a support person – among other grounds, appellant alleged Commission did not properly interpret the concept of ‘valid reason’ as expounded in Rode and that respondent was ‘tardy’ in delivering documents which the Commission ordered to produce – Full Bench satisfied Commission had not erred in its assessment of the transfer of business and the application of the new agreement on the PIP – appellant had not raised his concerns with the respondent at the time, and that he bore some responsibility as an Executive Level employee for staying informed – not persuaded that Commission erred in consideration of any part of evidence – found appellant was not denied reasonable opportunity for support person – satisfied Commission set out relevant case law concerning valid reason and applied them correctly – satisfied that respondent complied with directions for production of documents – Full bench not satisfied findings by Commission were made in error – appellant had not identified any issue which raised matters of importance that would be sufficient to enliven public interest – findings of Commission in first instance were harmonious with other decisions of the Commission – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Knight against decision of Kovacic DP of 5 May 2017 [[2017] FWC 2488] Re: Commonwealth of Australia (Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission)