NEWS HR

CASE PROCEDURES – stay order – ss.400, 604, 606 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal against decision of Hampton C of 20 July 2017 – Commission determined employee’s dismissal unfair as it was harsh and concluded reinstatement was an appropriate remedy – appellant seeks a stay of the whole of the decision pending the hearing and determination of the appeal – employee resumed employment and is currently completing an induction which would enable him to recommence his duties as an driver – appellant pressed stay application with some urgency as not to allow employee to resume driving duties – Commission not persuaded appellant’s argument had reasonable prospects of success and therefore not persuaded the balance of convenience favours the grant of a stay – a stay would deprive the employee of income which would flow to him as a consequence of the reinstatement order – application for a stay order dismissed. Appeal by Reliable Petroleum P/L against decision of Hampton C of 20 July 2017 [[2017] FWC 3552] Re: Murray

CASE PROCEDURES – referring question of law – s.608 Fair Work Act 2009 – President delegated function and powers under s.608 of FW Act to Vice President – question sought to be referred to Federal Court concern validity of sections of FW Act pertaining to when a person is protected from unfair dismissal – Vice President satisfied proposed question is one of law however not satisfied the question of law arose in a matter before the Commission – application dismissed. Calleri v Swinburne University of Technology

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appellant’s application for an unfair dismissal remedy was lodged 8 months outside statutory time limit – at first instance Commission not satisfied there were any exceptional circumstances that warranted the granting of an extension of time – Full Bench asked the appellant about his general protections application – formed the view that the appellant will require leave of the Federal Court of Australia (FCA) or the Federal Circuit Court (FCC) to correct his application to a general protections application involving dismissal (s.365) – if leave is granted by the FCA or the FCC appellant will have to determine whether to pursue his s.394 or s.365 application – s.725 of the FW Act prevents the appellant from making a s.365 application until after the unfair dismissal application has been withdrawn, failed for want of jurisdiction or failed because the dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy – appellant elected to proceed with s.365 application and requested that no further hearing occur on this matter – appellant requested reasons in relation to his appeal – Full Bench determined the question of permission to appeal – noted permission to appeal must not be granted unless the Commission considers that it is in the public interest to do so – appeals on questions of fact may only be made on the basis that the decision involved a ‘significant error of fact’ – appellant submitted Commission failed to be guided by the rules of fairness and independence – erred by considering the extension of time before considering the minimum employment period and employment status – erred in not finding that there were exceptional circumstances – Full Bench not satisfied that there was an arguable case of error – not satisfied that it would be in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Raza against decision of Dean DP of 23 March 2017 [[2017] FWC 1662] Re: Harbour Roof Tiling P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – ss.180, 186, 188, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission approved the Lendlease Engineering P/L New South Wales Enterprise Agreement 2016 (Agreement) – permission granted for parties to be represented – appellant grounds of appeal were the Agreement contained a false and misleading representation; the Commission erred in finding Agreement complied with s.186(2)(a) and 188(c) of the Act and the respondent failed to take all reasonable steps to ensure relevant employees employed at the time covered by the proposed agreement were given copies of other material incorporated by reference in the proposed agreement during access period – Respondent submitted permission to appeal should be refused and appeal be dismissed – Full Bench did not agree with submissions provided by appellant [KCL Industries, Sparta mining, NTEU] – not satisfied permission to grant appeal was in the public interest [GlaxoSmithKline] – not satisfied there is an arguable case of error [House v The King] – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Roe C of 6 June 2017 [[2017] FWC 3080] Re: Lendlease Engineering P/L

CASE PROCEDURES – evidence – s.590 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – application for termination of agreement after its nominal expiry – previous order issued 9 June 2017 – on 15 July 2017 Ms Vickers sent a number of documents including an amended application for an order for the production of documents (15 July application) against Wesfarmers and its controlled entities including Coles – Coles characterised 15 July application as lacking a legitimate forensic purpose and Ms Vickers had no basis to advance the serious allegations that she had made against Coles – Full Bench inferred Ms Vickers intended to test adequacy of Coles response to previous order – application made too late for Commission’s consideration before 17 July hearing – Coles and Wesfarmers submitted application made too late – Ms Vickers further submitted Coles produced few relevant documents; the evidence demonstrated Coles not made reasonable effort to comply with order; no basis for any order for production upon Wesfarmers to be restricted as there may have been relevant documents held by Wesfarmers that did not reach the board level; Cole’s decision to limit scope of undertakings relating to the 2014 Agreement established Coles culpability; representatives of Coles could give ‘direct evidence’ about documents held by Coles and Wesfarmers – Coles submitted Ms Vickers had provided no reason for proposed expansion; no utility to include authorisation of any person; extension unwarranted and oppressive and further broadening amounted to a requirement for general discovery – Full Bench found decision to enter into and apply for the approval of 2014 Agreement was made internally within Coles – no documents pertaining to the authorisation or sanctioning of 2014 Agreement – declined to exercise discretion in favour of making the orders sought by Ms Vickers in respect of Wesfarmers – also declined to make orders for production directed to controlled entities – order sought in 15 July application not issued instead issued order for production attached to Full Bench’s decision – authorised officer of Coles Supermarkets Australia P/L and Bi-Lo P/L directed to file and serve on Ms Vickers an affidavit verifying compliance with attached order for production and the order for production issued on 9 June 2017. Coles Supermarkets Australia P/L and Bi-Lo P/L Retail Agreement 2011

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contract for specified term – ss.386, 394, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – in decision at first instance the Commission felt bound by the decision in Lunn – concluded appellant’s employment was not terminated at the initiative of employer and anti-avoidance provision in s.386(3) of FW Act did not apply – application dismissed – decision appealed on the basis that Commission erred in relying on decision in Lunn and erred in finding that the antiavoidance provision was not engaged – appellant submitted that Lunn wrongly focuses upon whether employment contract was terminated on employer’s initiative, rather than employment relationship – submitted that application of Lunn to provisions of FW Act incompatible – submitted that Commission erroneously approached s.386(3) of FW Act on basis that there could only be one substantial purpose for an employer entering into outer limit contracts and conclusions regarding anti-avoidance provision was not supported by evidence – Full Bench found that in first instance, Commission did not error in finding that avoidance was not a substantial purpose of using outer limit contracts – found in the public interest that permission to appeal be granted in relation to first ground of appeal and not second – permission to appeal granted – directions to be issued for the hearing and determination of the appeal. Appeal by Khayam against decision of Hunt C of 22 May 2017 [[2017] FWC 1524] Re: Navitas English P/L t/a Navitas English

MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – in a Statement issued on 6 July 2016 [[2017] FWCFB 4495] it was proposed that the National Training Wage Schedule (the NTW Schedule) be standardised and removed from all awards except the Miscellaneous Award 2010 (Miscellaneous Award) and be incorporated by reference to the Miscellaneous Award – in a Statement issued on 23 February 2017 [[2017] FWCFB 1095] the Full Bench announced that the NTW Schedule of the Miscellaneous Award would be re-drafted in plain language – Full Bench made provisional view that NTW Schedule would be tailored to a particular modern award on request – Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) and Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union – Construction and General Division (CFMEU) subsequently applied to maintain award-specific schedules in a number of awards – in a decision issued on 9 June 2017 [[2017] FWCFB 3176] a reference term to the Miscellaneous Award was inserted into 94 modern awards – Full Bench confirmed that award-specific schedules will be maintained in nine modern awards – terms of the award-specific NTW Schedules to be dealt with after finalisation of plain language NTW Schedule in the Miscellaneous Award – draft determinations incorporating the reference term published 13 June 2017 – final determinations were issued and came into operation on 1 July 2017 – submissions received from several parties in response to plain language drafting of NTW Schedule – conference held 21 July 2017 to discuss outstanding issues – decision concerns finalisation of terms of plain language NTW Schedule – an updated NTW Schedule is set out in Attachment A of decision – parties were required to provide any comments on the draft by 18 August 2017 – a determination varying the schedule in the Miscellaneous Award will then be issued – draft schedules of the nine awardspecific NTW Schedules will be published in week commencing 21 August 2017 – submissions are invited to comment on the draft schedules by 4pm Friday on 8 September 2017 – reply submissions are invited by no later than 4pm on Friday 22 September 2017 – Full Bench to determine content of the awardspecific NTW Schedules and whether they should be included in the nine modern awards on the papers – any requests for oral hearing to be made by 4pm on Tuesday 25 September 2017 – submissions to be sent to [email protected]. 4 yearly review of modern awards – National Training Wage

Thirty-one unfair dismissal and labour dispute applications are scheduled for hearing by the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Geelong Window Solutions (Balcam), Australia JW Trading Pty Ltd & H & Y Investment & Development Pty Ltd (Guan), Buehler Aged Care Pty Ltd (Mercer), Churchill Management Pty Ltd (Athanates), Amtek Corporation Pty Ltd (Young), Holcim (Australia) Pty Ltd (Harland), Retirees WA (inc.) (Pereira), Lockin Pty Ltd (Ware), Premier Motor Service Pty Ltd (Tischler), The GEO Group Australia Pty Ltd (Patel, Reihana, Reilly), Spectrum Community Focus Limited (Valenzuela), Premier Youthworks (Rosberg), Hopgoods Bus Service P/L (Morale), Nunga Mi:Minar Incorporated (Joy), BizFine Pty Ltd (Pugh), Rio Tinto Coal (NSW) Pty Ltd (Murray (nee McCauley)), Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Grey), Valoriza Water Australia Pty Ltd (Cooper), Evertwin Pty Ltd (Buchanan), Portugal Madeira Sydney Social & Cultural Sports Club Ltd (Croad), Winder Controls Australia Pty Ltd (Ghate), Cerebos (Australia) Limited (Ratcliffe), St Marys Area Community Development Project. inc. (SMACD) (Lees, Moore), Custom Bus (Sarmento), TB Hotels Pty Ltd (Hogan), Pathways Australia Pty Ltd (Hill), Knoxfield Medical Centre Pty Ltd (Logan), Diamond Logistics Pty Ltd (Luapo).